List your B&F Top Ten after 10 Rounds

[Claret]

Who do you think would be leading the Swan's Best and Fairest after 10 rounds . . . .

Claret's Verdict

1. Kirk
2. O'Keefe
3. Jolly
4. McVeigh
5. C Bolton
6. Bevan
7. Micky O
8. Goodes
9. Jack
10. Mattner

[eggbeater]

I would put Goodes at 3

[bloodboy]

Magic is having a fanstastic season...27 goals already...really stepped it up in Bazz's absence.

[doctor swan]

1. kirk
2. o 'keefe
3. jolly
4.i ll eat lots of humble pie here mcveigh

[ScottH]

1. ROK
2. Jolly
3. Kirk
4. Jack
5. Moore
6. McVeigh
7. Goodes
8. MOL
9. Kennelly
10. Mattner

[liz]

Kirk
ROK
McVeigh
C Bolts
Goodes
Jolly
Mattner
Magic
Moore
Leo

The spot is difficult to fill and I'm not overly confident at all in my list. This has been one of the most even seasons with Swans right across the board making very telling contributions at times. People remember two bad games from Leo but his other 8 have been pretty damn good. Yet Jack, Teddy and Bevo have all been pretty good too.

And to think that three of probably our best half dozen players aren't in there - ie Hall, Malceski and Kennelly - which bodes reasonably well for the second half of the season.

[Nico]

Mattner must be in the top 5, he has been outstanding.

[SimonH]

Haven't seen enough to give a top 10, but from those games I have seen, I think that the following 4 have been a class above, in a pretty even side:

Goodes
Moore
Kirk
Jolly.

Very honourable mentions to ROK and MOL.

[gossipcom]

Okay this isn't my final order, but at the moment I've got them as:

1. Kirk
2. MO'L
3. Goodes
4. RO'K
5. Jolly
6. Mattner
7. McVeigh
8. Moore
9. Jack
10. Barry / Craig Bolton

The Most Improved would be a tie between McVeigh or Moore at the moment.

ETA: Because I originally had RO'K in there and accidentally deleted him.

[liz]

Okay this isn't my final order, but at the moment I've got them as:

1. Kirk
2. MO'L
3. Goodes
4. Jolly
5. Mattner
6. McVeigh
7. Moore
8. Jack
9. Barry
10. Craig Bolton

The Most Improved would be a tie between McVeigh or Moore at the moment.

No ROK in your top 10? He's barely played a mediocre game and in several has been absolutely outstanding.

[gossipcom]

Whoops I was editing that list before and had him in there must have deleted his name in the C&P process. Shall edit it now.

[reigning premier]

1. Kirk.
2. ROK
3. McVeigh
4. B2
5. MO'L
6. Mattner
7. Moore
8.5 Goodes
8.5 Jolly
10. Jack

[Jewels]

1. RyanO
2. Captain
3. Goodesy
4. Marty
5. Dr Jolly
6. CBolts
7. Mickey O
8. Moore
9. McHack
10.Teddy

[Zlatorog]

My top ten so far:

1. Kirk
2. ROK
3. MOL
4. Jolly
5. B2
6. Goodes
7. McVeigh
8. Kennelly
9. Mattner
10. Moore/Bird/Jack/Bevan

[ScottH]

I haven't got him in my top 10, but I reckon he'd be there still ATM, given his early form.

B Hall.