Tribunal has me confused

Collapse
X
 
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts
  • Dogzbody
    On the Rookie List
    • Jul 2008
    • 282

    Tribunal has me confused

    Stephen Browne gets 4 weeks (possibly reduced to 3 but still) for Porplysia's KO

    Does anyone else think this is a bit steep? Porpoise pretty much bounced into him and although he braced for the impact I couldn't see how Browne could have avoided the impact.

    They played it about 500 times during the coverage, and there seemed nothing in it in terms of malice or even rough conduct, more so just unfortunate.

    AFL is a 360 degree sport with big strong bodies hitting each other at speed, these things will happen. If you consider that Amon got 4 weeks for a blatant flying charge into Luke Hodge's head for the same sanction (and Amon is no angel) Stephen Browne can consider himself unlucky I reckon.

    Does this mean that the level of the suspension relates to the proceeding health of the recipient player?
    Last edited by Dogzbody; 5 August 2008, 12:14 PM.
    "We talked five times. I called him twice, and he called me twice." :confused: :confused: :confused: :D

    Eddie McGuire
  • Mike_B
    Peyow Peyow
    • Jan 2003
    • 6267

    #2
    I was confused by this as well. I guess we will see what the story is once it hits the tribunal...

    I'm on the Chandwagon!!!

    If you cannot compete for the premiership, it's better to be young and exciting than middle-aged and dowdy.

    Comment

    • 573v30
      On the bandwagon...
      • Sep 2005
      • 5017

      #3
      Milburn gets one week, Browne cleared

      No surprises really.
      I only support one team: The SYDNEY SWANS!!!!! :adore

      Comment

      • sidswan
        Warming the Bench
        • Oct 2007
        • 206

        #4
        I disagree that Amon's was a blatant flying charge, he's great friends with Luke Hodge.....surely it was just mis-timed and spontaneous, maybe a bit reckless.....I thought he was extremely unlucky to get 4 wks .....or am I just naive?

        Comment

        • DeadlyAkkuret
          Veterans List
          • Oct 2006
          • 4547

          #5
          Unbelievable that Milburn could cop any less than 3 for that one. Can someone explain how on Earth he had it downgraded from 4 to 1?

          Comment

          • NMWBloods
            Taking Refuge!!
            • Jan 2003
            • 15819

            #6
            Originally posted by DeadlyAkkuret
            Unbelievable that Milburn could cop any less than 3 for that one. Can someone explain how on Earth he had it downgraded from 4 to 1?
            Quite simple. It was 4 weeks originally as it was considered high. Geelong argued that the contact between players is what matters hence it was no longer high and thus 3 weeks. Drop 2 weeks for guilty plea and good record to get 1 week. Probably about right.
            Captain Logic is not steering this tugboat.

            "[T]here are things that matter more and he's reading and thinking about them: heaven, reincarnation. Life and death are the only things that are truly a matter of life and death. Not football."

            Comment

            • DeadlyAkkuret
              Veterans List
              • Oct 2006
              • 4547

              #7
              I think driving a player's face into the turf should be considered high.

              Comment

              • Triple B
                Formerly 'BBB'
                • Feb 2003
                • 6999

                #8
                Originally posted by NMWBloods
                ......good record to get 1 week. Probably about right.
                Can't disagree more.

                He had absolutely no intention other than to inflict as much hurt and pain as possible. He succeeded by forcefully, and purposely, driving the players head/face into the ground. The ball was gone, he knew the ball was gone yet still gritted his teeth and let him have it.

                Cannot believe you think 1 week seems about right.
                Driver of the Dan Hannebery bandwagon....all aboard. 4th April 09

                Comment

                • NMWBloods
                  Taking Refuge!!
                  • Jan 2003
                  • 15819

                  #9
                  Originally posted by Triple B
                  Cannot believe you think 1 week seems about right.
                  After the 2 week discount.
                  Captain Logic is not steering this tugboat.

                  "[T]here are things that matter more and he's reading and thinking about them: heaven, reincarnation. Life and death are the only things that are truly a matter of life and death. Not football."

                  Comment

                  • ScottH
                    It's Goodes to cheer!!
                    • Sep 2003
                    • 23665

                    #10
                    Saw the Browne one last night.
                    I'd have to agree that the penalty seems a bit high, for an innocuous bump.

                    Comment

                    • Triple B
                      Formerly 'BBB'
                      • Feb 2003
                      • 6999

                      #11
                      Originally posted by ScottH
                      Saw the Browne one last night.
                      I'd have to agree that the penalty seems a bit high, for an innocuous bump.
                      He got off completely. So he should have.
                      Driver of the Dan Hannebery bandwagon....all aboard. 4th April 09

                      Comment

                      • ScottH
                        It's Goodes to cheer!!
                        • Sep 2003
                        • 23665

                        #12
                        Originally posted by Triple B
                        He got off completely. So he should have.
                        Yeh, so I heard. A bit bizarre.

                        Comment

                        • Dogzbody
                          On the Rookie List
                          • Jul 2008
                          • 282

                          #13
                          Good to see the Browne one got thrown out.

                          Milburn though
                          "We talked five times. I called him twice, and he called me twice." :confused: :confused: :confused: :D

                          Eddie McGuire

                          Comment

                          • TheHood
                            On the Rookie List
                            • Jan 2003
                            • 1938

                            #14
                            What if the Milburn hit had caused bruising to the brain? One suspects it would be the talk of the week and tribunal laws would be rewritten.

                            The action of Milburn was deliberate rough conduct that could have resulted in very serious injury, the fact it wasn't in play makes it borderline assault!
                            Last edited by TheHood; 7 August 2008, 12:47 PM.
                            The Pain of Discipline is Nothing Like The Pain of Disappointment

                            Comment

                            • Dogzbody
                              On the Rookie List
                              • Jul 2008
                              • 282

                              #15
                              Which again begs me to question...is the recipient player health a key part in deciding the punishment?
                              "We talked five times. I called him twice, and he called me twice." :confused: :confused: :confused: :D

                              Eddie McGuire

                              Comment

                              Working...