Coaching panel

[liz]

I thought I'd read Stone's departure from Melbourne described as "retirement".

[Mountain Man]

I wonder what we can expect from the Swans game plan given the coach changes. It will be fascinating to see, given that the changes are so large. There are others who will have much better insights than my experience in the game and in their knowledge of the coaches as players.

Do we get a continuation of Horse's 'pressure' above all else? Is he still the decision maker on all structures and player selections? So maybe nothing much changes to the game plan after all?

Or does Johnson have a free hand to redesign the forward structure. If so, what does he say both to Buddy, and the other forwards about their structure and positions - and what 'authority' does he have in 'negotiating' with the midfield coach about how the midfield will deliver into the forward 50?

How do Kirk and Cox work together on clearances? As players, they had very different skills, and it is another thing again to analyse the talent they will have to work with from the Swans playing group. I'd love to hear the instructions to Joey about how to play! Does Johnson get told how the delivery will be; or vice versa.

Will Shaw convert the 'one on one' defense ethic to a mad dash running style? Can Shaw still 'demand' from the midfield coach the same degree of 2 way running? What instructions does Rampe have for 2018? Does Mills still remain a 'backman'?

etc etc etc

I imagine some pretty intense discussions and strategies; presumably needing resolution before the players come back from their holidays.

And then, do Buddy and Joey adapt to new instructions, or continue to perform admirably to their strengths, without fully accepting the new.

It seems to that if ever there was a potential for a slow start to a season, 2018 has potential!

[Markwebbos]

I?m imaging Cox taps it down to Kirk, stoppage-wise

[stevoswan]

I wonder what we can expect from the Swans game plan given the coach changes. It will be fascinating to see, given that the changes are so large. There are others who will have much better insights than my experience in the game and in their knowledge of the coaches as players.

Do we get a continuation of Horse's 'pressure' above all else? Is he still the decision maker on all structures and player selections? So maybe nothing much changes to the game plan after all?

Or does Johnson have a free hand to redesign the forward structure. If so, what does he say both to Buddy, and the other forwards about their structure and positions - and what 'authority' does he have in 'negotiating' with the midfield coach about how the midfield will deliver into the forward 50?

How do Kirk and Cox work together on clearances? As players, they had very different skills, and it is another thing again to analyse the talent they will have to work with from the Swans playing group. I'd love to hear the instructions to Joey about how to play! Does Johnson get told how the delivery will be; or vice versa.

Will Shaw convert the 'one on one' defense ethic to a mad dash running style? Can Shaw still 'demand' from the midfield coach the same degree of 2 way running? What instructions does Rampe have for 2018? Does Mills still remain a 'backman'?

etc etc etc

I imagine some pretty intense discussions and strategies; presumably needing resolution before the players come back from their holidays.

And then, do Buddy and Joey adapt to new instructions, or continue to perform admirably to their strengths, without fully accepting the new.

It seems to that if ever there was a potential for a slow start to a season, 2018 has potential!

May I say that the above is a very 'glass half empty' attitude. Fair enough to speculate, we are all wondering how this will all pan out....but the level of talent coming in is exciting to me. Harley has been with us long enough to know what is expected at the Swans, he also knows Johnson very well and he obviously thinks SJ will be a good fit for us. Cox is just a huge talent and, by all accounts, an excellent 'strategist', so should bring refreshing ideas and Shawry is a long time Swan and a senior coach in the making (was great with the two's) so will fit right in. These changes should be seen as a positive step for our club and I for one believe we will improve for the better. It's not as if we haven't had coaching panel changes in the past, albeit not as wholesale as these. As long as we become more efficient, play better and get better results and I think we will.......but at this point, it's all academic.

[Nico]

I doubt whether we will change the pressure at all costs style. The players and the team just have to do it better. The Tigers did it better than any team in 2017 and won the flag. I wouldn't be surprised if they used our blueprint and did it better. They have more pace than us.

[RogueSwan]

I doubt whether we will change the pressure at all costs style. The players and the team just have to do it better....

and if they do have an off game just please don't have it during a do-or-die final (or against the Hawks).

[ScottH]

A lifetime in football | Barossa & Light Herald

Former Nuriootpa High School history teacher Andrew Scholefield has been the Sydney Swans' SA recruiting officer for 24 years.

He has spent the past 24 years as the Sydney recruiting officer in SA and was involved in numerous SA and WA footballers being drafted to the Swans.

These include icons of the game like Michael O?Loughlin, Adam Goodes, premiership player Nic Fosdike, father-son selection Stephen Doyle and in recent years, George Hewitt.

[stevoswan]

I see the Schneiderman has joined GWS to coach their reserves http://www.afl.com.au/news/2017-10-1...iants-reserves. He joins Adam Buchanan there, who has moved into an assistant coaching role looking after stoppages. They like ex-Swans don't they?

[ugg]

I see the Schneiderman has joined GWS to coach their reserves Ex-Saint, Swan to coach Giants' reserves - AFL.com.au. He joins Adam Buchanan there, who has moved into an assistant coaching role looking after stoppages. They like ex-Swans don't they?

The GWS hiring committee couldn't tell them apart either. Might as well have both!

[RogueSwan]

... He joins Adam Buchanan there, who has moved into an assistant coaching role looking after stoppages. They like ex-Swans don't they?

Is that Amon's brother?

[Go Swannies]

Is that Amon's brother?

Shh. It was the Swans' Fine Cotton time - we played them alternate weeks. Got them and Schneiderman as a job lot from the Muppetts.

[stevoswan]

Is that Amon's brother?

Oh @@@@!!