Team Changes for Round VIII v Bombers

Collapse
X
 
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts
  • MattW
    Veterans List
    • May 2011
    • 4208

    Team List Team Changes for Round VIII v Bombers

    I'm moving on.

    OUT: Cunningham, Jack, Blakey
    IN: O'Riordan, Stoddart, Franklin

    I understand the theory behind playing Kieren - older player providing leadership and steadiness to young team - but he's not playing well and is effectively taking the spot of a developing player. ROK was playing at a higher level when demoted, and I know the circumstances are different, but it's a precedent for the good of the team trumping sentiment.

    Cunningham has been, with Rampe and Joey, among our best players this year and so his absence will hurt. But it must give O'Riordan a shot at it. I will be aggrieved if Clarke comes in instead.

    Let's get Stoddart in to give us some pop in transition and long kicking. I know he's not going to solve our contested ball problems but he might help us get it out of the stoppages and spread it.

    Blakey shows glimpses, but is a bit slight and too much is being expected of him. I'd like to see him build touch in the NEAFL.
  • Swanny40519
    Regular in the side.
    • Oct 2012
    • 469

    #2
    Based on what MC has done so far this year :

    Out: Cunnimgham, Blakey
    In: Franklin, Clarke

    However in my rusted on supporter mode:

    Out: Cunningham, Reid, Heeney (must be injured playing that bad)
    In: Franklin, Cameron, COR

    Comment

    • rb4x
      Regular in the Side
      • Dec 2007
      • 968

      #3
      Out Match Selection Committee, In RWO Selection Committee. Could not do worse than the current lot though would need access to accurate injury details which are NOT provided to the AFL website.

      Comment

      • Ralph Dawg
        Senior Player
        • Apr 2018
        • 1729

        #4
        Ins: Cameron COR Franklin Stoddart
        Outs: Reid Cunningham Blakey Jack
        Cameron to ruck, Sinclair tall marking forward. COR take Mills spot, Stoddart replace Harry, Mills play mid, Parker/Heeney play Jack's forward position. Buddy straight in for Blakey.

        Comment

        • Markwebbos
          Veterans List
          • Jul 2016
          • 7186

          #5
          Originally posted by Ralph Dawg
          Ins: Cameron COR Franklin Stoddart
          Outs: Reid Cunningham Blakey Jack
          Cameron to ruck, Sinclair tall marking forward. COR take Mills spot, Stoddart replace Harry, Mills play mid, Parker/Heeney play Jack's forward position. Buddy straight in for Blakey.
          Those are all eminently sensible suggestions. However, I think it's highly unlikely they'll drop Reid, despite his being unbelievably underwhelming this year. 8 disposals and 8 tackles yesterday. Perhaps they've given him the Gary Rohan role?

          Not sure quite what Cameron or COR need to do to get a game.

          I'm just praying that we don't see Jack or Clarke in the side for quite some time.

          OUTS: Cunningham, Jack, Blakey
          IN: COR, Buddy, Stoddart
          Last edited by Markwebbos; 5 May 2019, 06:49 PM.

          Comment

          • Mel_C
            Veterans List
            • Jan 2003
            • 4470

            #6
            Was walking passed a group of Essendon supporters after the Geelong game today and heard the following conversation.

            "Who do we play next week?"
            "The swans".
            "In Sydney?"
            "Yes"
            "We should win that."
            "Yeah the swans are poo."
            "Yeah they are really bad."

            It's been awhile since we've been spoken about like that...but unfortunately they're not wrong ????.

            They did worry about Buddy though because he loves playing against them.

            Comment

            • Agent 86
              Senior Player
              • Aug 2004
              • 1686

              #7
              Originally posted by Markwebbos
              Those are all eminently sensible suggestions. However, I think it's highly unlikely they'll drop Reid, despite his been unbelievably underwhelming this year. 8 disposals and 8 tackles yesterday. Perhaps they've given him the Gary Rohan role?

              Not sure quite what Cameron or COR need to do to get a game.

              I'm just praying that we don't see Jack or Clarke in the side for quite some time.

              OUTS: Cunningham, Jack, Blakey
              IN: COR, Buddy, Stoddart
              Things are not good when losing Harry C is seen as a big blow, but I reckon he's been pretty solid. He will be missed.

              I wouldn't drop Blakey.

              Jack? Probably yes, but don't think it will happen.

              I think Clarke will get a run this week.

              As for what Darcy & COR need to do… IDK, but they're not exactly knocking the door down, right?

              Comment

              • Markwebbos
                Veterans List
                • Jul 2016
                • 7186

                #8
                Originally posted by Agent 86
                Things are not good when losing Harry C is seen as a big blow, but I reckon he's been pretty solid. He will be missed.

                I wouldn't drop Blakey.

                Jack? Probably yes, but don't think it will happen.

                I think Clarke will get a run this week.

                As for what Darcy & COR need to do… IDK, but they're not exactly knocking the door down, right?
                COR has been in the bests every week I believe.

                Comment

                • Ralph Dawg
                  Senior Player
                  • Apr 2018
                  • 1729

                  #9
                  Originally posted by Agent 86
                  Things are not good when losing Harry C is seen as a big blow, but I reckon he's been pretty solid. He will be missed.

                  I wouldn't drop Blakey.

                  Jack? Probably yes, but don't think it will happen.

                  I think Clarke will get a run this week.

                  As for what Darcy & COR need to do… IDK, but they're not exactly knocking the door down, right?
                  I suspect you are correct in what the match committee is going to do. Clarke in for Harry, Buddy in for McCartain or Blakey. The problem with this is that these selections, coupled with the same game plan, will send the message that the coaches do not acknowledge anything needs to be done and are just paying lip service to the notion that a rebuild is required. If they think the return of our ageing and/or busted stars ( Reg, Macca, Smith, Naismith, Menzel) will fix things, they are deluded. The ultimate aim is to win a flag and supporters are happy to cop losses if they can see that the club is working towards this, even if it's in the long term.

                  Comment

                  • 707
                    Veterans List
                    • Aug 2009
                    • 6204

                    #10
                    Still mopping up my spew from last week when the MC managed to not pick COR. Loading up for another big spew when they do the same this week and instead of correctly bringing in COR they bring in butcher Clarke instead.

                    On a good note I managed to get a decent bet on Essendon yesterday at $1.65 before the bookies woke up and wound them in to $1.40 ish later on. Early betting often gives generous odds.

                    Comment

                    • KSAS
                      Senior Player
                      • Mar 2018
                      • 1785

                      #11
                      OUT: Cunningham, Blakey, Jack
                      IN: COR, Buddy, Rose
                      I fear like most that Clarke will be recalled.

                      Comment

                      • stevoswan
                        Veterans List
                        • Sep 2014
                        • 8548

                        #12
                        Originally posted by KSAS
                        OUT: Cunningham, Blakey, Jack
                        IN: COR, Buddy, Rose
                        I fear like most that Clarke will be recalled.
                        Do the coaches not see him butchering the ball week in, week out?

                        We want quality, not quantity! Don't they too?

                        I'd go OUT: Cunningham, Jack

                        IN: Buddy, COR.

                        If they don't select COR this week, I wouldn't blame him if he instructed his manager to start putting the 'feelers' out.....

                        Comment

                        • Scottee
                          Senior Player
                          • Aug 2003
                          • 1585

                          #13
                          Just my 2 cents worth on the possible ins.

                          COR was a class above on the weekend against top opposition. To me he is a mid, not a half back, he has a real knack in traffic and he doesn't give up. He needs to be persevered with in the ones.

                          Clarke was very good at making position and gut running on the weekend, but yes, he is a liability with his disposal, which seems to be in a panic a lot of the time. He may just need some time to settle down because if he can improve his disposal he will be a real asset.

                          Rowbottom looked very good on the weekend without setting the world on fire. He should get as much senior experience as he doesn't seem to have any big weaknesses in his game.

                          Stoddart looks good but he is very light and has not filled out. Finds it hard to win a one on one. Would be alright if we were winning the midfield battles but we are not.

                          Cameron. Knows how to play, is a great mark and a good kick.With Sinclairs form he might be a wise choice in the near future in support of Sinclair.

                          Rose is the only other one ready to play senior football, one of the fastest in the side and one of the best kicks with a good ability to read the play and kick a goal. Needs to be given a shot in the current circumstances.

                          I am not criticisng the rest of the seconds players; they are mostly project players who are steadily improving. Probably the closest of the rest would be Pink in the event of us losing another KPP, but not at the moment.

                          It will depend on the outs but COR would be at the top of the list imho for Cunningham. Rowbotton for Jack (changing of the guard time, love KJ, but its time).Probably Buddy for Blakey otherwise.
                          We have them where we want them, everything is going according to plan!

                          Comment

                          • waswan
                            Senior Player
                            • Oct 2015
                            • 2047

                            #14
                            Perris for Longmire

                            Comment

                            • Roadrunner
                              Senior Player
                              • Jan 2018
                              • 1464

                              #15
                              Hi guys, I recommend the following changes:

                              1. COR back pocket and take kick ins.
                              2. Move Mills to midfield for next 4-5 games to see if he can make it
                              3. Bring in Cameron to ruck, with Sinkers forward- we need 2 ruckmen when we are being smashed in clearances.
                              4.Move Lloyd to the wing, otherwise to the NEAFL.
                              5. Move Blakey to the wing, otherwise NEAFL.
                              6. Stop putting an extra man in defense-we need to attack more and if we lose attacking, so be it.
                              7. Play our youngsters to see if they are any good at AFL level: Stodard, Rowbottom and McInerny This season is gone.
                              8. Cut out the silly handpasses to a player under pressure- what's the point? Kick the ball if you can't get a handball away to a player who is unguarded-sorry, I forgot you can't kick to a team mate! Oh well..........

                              Comment

                              Working...