Tilt or Dunkley

[Sanecow]

If we could have one of them back (at their best) for season '06 who would you take?

[ScottH]

Dunkley, "not many could out mark him, but I did once." - Paul Kelly.

[goswannie14]

Tilt ...Dunkley doesn't even come into that equation as good as he was

[arht]

Re: Tilt or Dunkley

Originally posted by Sanecow
If we could have one of them back (at their best) for season '06 who would you take?

Tilt for sure ... Dunkley was a great mark, but his disposal left us in trouble most of the time ... his "look to handball" followed by long to the wing made him a bit of a liablity coming out of defense - having said that, his play on Carey was always outstanding and a joy to watch (especially the "accidental" whacks to Carey's head). But Tilt was a damn good kick and a good defender ... overall he wins ... plus he was much more fun to take the mickey out of before every kick in.

[Lucky Knickers]

Tilt.

[Nico]

Dead heat, cant pick it.