Who would you prefer?

[Charlie]

Well?

[monopoly19]

I voted McGlone, but it would depend if Seymour/Nicks were still on the list. I wouldn't want McGlone + a whole heap of rookies/young trades in place of some experience.

[TheHood]

I wouldn't know McGlone if he jumped out of my muslie tomorrow morning but I reckon he has to be better than Warfey.

[Charlie]

Originally posted by TheHood
I wouldn't know McGlone if he jumped out of my muslie tomorrow morning but I reckon he has to be better than Warfey.

lol... neither would I. With absolutely no access to the reserves here in Melbourne, I have to rely on reports here and on the official site. From the sounds of it, McGlone was among the best most weeks... and that means he's got to be more value than Warfe.

Don't get me wrong, I think that in earlier years Warfe was a very good player and he'd probably still be a very good player had he not had so many injuries. But the time has come.

[penga]

IMO, experience (warfe's experience anyway) is overrated

[Bleed Red Blood]

Originally posted by Charlie
lol... neither would I. With absolutely no access to the reserves here in Melbourne, I have to rely on reports here and on the official site. From the sounds of it, McGlone was among the best most weeks... and that means he's got to be more value than Warfe.

Don't get me wrong, I think that in earlier years Warfe was a very good player and he'd probably still be a very good player had he not had so many injuries. But the time has come.

Completely agree with that - everything I've heard about McGlone is good news and most definetly Warfe is past it.

[robbieando]

I would prefer the Easter Bunny

[Plugger46]

I've been a Warfe fan (as most people would know), but an ordinary couple of years with injury, and then struggling to re-capture some form, sees his career at the Crossroads. I don't know anything about McGlone, and have never seen him play.

So I'm undecided.

[Destructive]

Just to piss Warfe's Babe off.....


Scott McGlone.

[jude_boltons_babe]

i would prefer scott mcglone

i think rowan is a good player but i think they should of kept scott mcglone he was a great player

[jixygirl]

McGlone because of the reports I heard of his form in the ressies.

[i'm-uninformed2]

where is the vote for "none of the above"?