Now, let's not get smug

Collapse
X
 
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts
  • sharp9
    Senior Player
    • Jan 2003
    • 2508

    Now, let's not get smug

    I was just listening to the Morning Glory team talking about the Bulldogs alleged gang rape, (by the way there are two Storm players facing rape charges too, at the moment) and it occurred to me that everyone sounded a bit smug.

    They talked about how AFL fights the good fight etc etc and how on-field violence was no longer accepted (remember when a cheap shot king hit was "just part of the game"?) and how on-field racism was the norm until those white knights who play, administer and watch the greatest game decided to clean it up. While that's basically true I reckon we should stop being smug and keep going down the path of making our game and the world a better place. One thing that stands out where the game is still well behind society is in it's attitude to gay men.

    Now, I'm married, as many of you may recall, but I am also and actor and musician so at any given time as many as half my working colleagues are gay. It's not something one thinks about. it's just part of life.

    I was really surprised, then, watching the 2003 Bulldogs game the other night, to see the reaction of Steve Quatermain and the other two commentators (SOS and Tim Lane) when a couple of Sydney fans started dancing with each other 'cos they were so excited. When the shot went to them I laughed 'cos it was so great to see how happy they were (no pun intended) and how much they were enjoying the game. And, also, I had never seen fans celebrating in such a camp manner. I thought It was brilliant. It was also indicitive of the fact that the S.C.G is geographically close to Gay Central Australia.

    The commentators, however, didn't share my reaction. They were, at first, gobsmacked and then laughed (at them, not with them) and then attempted to make Gay puns. Frankly they giggled like fifteen year old schoolboys from Wagga on their first trip to Chapel St. I found it really interesting and I guarantee that a lot of you are reading this thinking "look it's a harmless comment, bit of fun." If you are thinking that then that is my point.

    What do you think would have happened if the shot had crossed to two Pacific Islanders doing a bit of traditional dancing and the commentators had laughed and said, "Bit of a boong celebration here in Sydney. Gee, it's a Black old night for the Bulldogs tonight. Dark times ahead for Peter Rohde, I reckon."?

    A couple of coomentators would have lost their jobs, is what would have happened. Right now some of you are going, "yea. but it's not the same thing." Sorry, but it is. If you don't understand that then you are in exactly the same position as those Collingwood supporters were in 10 years ago.

    To illustrate my point, we have all heard tha Nathan Brown was set to play a gay doctor on Bulger, M.D. The doctor's name? Dr. Pink. If you don't understand that this is homophobic, then you have a lot to learn.

    There is a simple rule of thumb for defining if the portrayl of a character is racist or homophobic and that is to ask the question "is their race, creed or sexuality considered a character trait?"

    Would a footy player play an Indian doctor called Dr. Curry? Not in this state, he wouldn't.

    The way to ask yourself if you are homphobic is to ask, "Do I think that two men dancing together is as valuable a way to celebrate a goal as waving the flags, banging the fence, doing a haka, or kissing the missus?" If you have to even pause to respond to that question then you have your answer right there.

    Question: How many gay men have played Ausssie Rules at the highest level?
    Answer: Probably a couple of hundred.
    Question: How many gay players have come out in public?
    Answer: Zero

    So, in short, we as fans and players have yet another avenue in which to be streets, (even generations) ahead of all the other footy codes in this country.

    Go Swannies!!! And see you at the game this afternoon.
    "I'll acknowledge there are more talented teams in the competition but I won't acknowledge that there is a better team in the competition" Paul Roos March 2005
  • TheHood
    On the Rookie List
    • Jan 2003
    • 1938

    #2
    I hate to use a generalisation for a generalisation, but I do remember that moment last year and I put it down to a Sydneyphobic Homophobic moment.

    It is a Melbourne footy thing. They just have not had enough exposure and hence they can only use rubbish humour like they would down the pub. It was poor taste and just showed a lack of experience with the gay community.

    Oh well, these things take time to move to a new generation (Pepsi yeah!).
    The Pain of Discipline is Nothing Like The Pain of Disappointment

    Comment

    • Bart
      CHHHOMMMMMPPP!!!!
      • Feb 2003
      • 1360

      #3
      Re: Now, let's not get smug

      Originally posted by sharp9
      I found it really interesting and I guarantee that a lot of you are reading this thinking "look it's a harmless comment, bit of fun." If you are thinking that then that is my point.

      I'm not sure whether this is really a footy related problem. Some people will take the comment in different ways. Some people will be offended, some will laugh. Its obviously politically incorrect to have a laugh these days at any minority groups expense, but who hasn't laughed at an Irish joke before. Funny how Irish jokes are never seen to be racist. Probably something to do with the fact that there is no group who poke more fun at themselves than the Irish.

      If someone likes to call a player or an umpire a fag at the footy, chances are they carry on the same at home and outside footy. I too am not gay, and would like to hear gay posters view on the SCG, but I don't really think that homophobic sentiment is rampant at Swans games. Sure you'll get a couple of drunk idiots, but I hope that the vast majority of use as members or fans are above that.

      Comment

      • BAM_BAM
        Support Staff
        • Jun 2003
        • 1820

        #4
        I remember the guys dancing around celebrating a goal. I laughed when I saw them as it looked like they were really enjoying themselves. I actually thought they were a couple of guys having a few drinks and getting very merry. It wasn't until the commentators started with the "having a gay old time in Sydney tonight" lines that made me look at them again and question whether they were gay. I admit that my taking that second look was wrong, not that I changed my view. They were expressing their joy at our teams performance. I do think though that the commentators should have a good long look at themselves.

        I have often thought about the openly gay sportsmen and women and the lack thereof. It reflects poorly on society today and our treatment of our fellow humans that these talented people hide their true selves in order to avoid criticism and ridicule, or dare I say to keep the sponsors happy.

        I have a gay relative and also some friends that are and I point out that they are gay for this topic only, when referring to them it's my cousin ...... or my friend ..... I also have two friends who have gay relatives. The relatives are girls and they are referred to as Uncle instead of Aunt. What hope do we have when your family will not or can not accept who you are.

        There's no easy answer to this.
        Here's my heart and you can break it
        I need some release, release, release
        We need
        Love and peace

        Comment

        Working...