Which Is The Better Flank?

[midaro]

Just for fun, which is better?

Mathews - Barry - Maxfield - Schneider - O'Keefe

OR

Crouch - Kennelly - Saddington - Williams - Davis

[Bleed Red Blood]

I choose the right flank as it has Davo and Saddo.

[midaro]

For me, the only clear choice is Davis over O'Keefe. I reckon the rest of the places could go down to personal preference.

[undy]

I choose the flank nearest me - I get very frustrated when the play spends a lot of time piddling about on the far side of the field. swing it to us !

[Mark]

"I choose the flank nearest me - I get very frustrated when the play spends a lot of time piddling about on the far side of the field. swing it to us "

Too right i blame the Club and the AFL for this !. Clearly there is a bias on which flank they run. Year in year out they promise to run down both flanks equally, but do they, NO!

Clearly we need supporter representatives from both flanks on the board of the Swans and the AFL ! Lets take it up with the club immediately

Sorry could not help myself !

[undy]

No need to apologise - I don't think that the AFL is to blame for this conspiracy, its probably Exxon's fault. I'm just trying to figure out the connection.

[ScottH]

Hard to pick a difference, except like everyone else davo.
Both look pretty awesome.

But, if I was the opposition coach I'd tell my players to go straight up the guts, stay away from the wings.... but wait I wonder who might be lurking up the centre of the ground?

[stellation]

I would go with
Crouch - Kennelly - Saddington - Williams - Davis

but, would change my mind if the other wing became
Mathews - Barry - Maxfield - Schneider - Davis

no offence ROK, but it's NICKY D !

[Destructive]

The 2nd option.

[SWANSBEST]

Frosties for sure.

[thommoone]

For me Williams and Davis over Schneider and Okeefe, experience and talent won out pretty easily, no offence to Rok and Schneider man though.

[ItsAllGoodes]

I love watching left footers so for me its

Mathews - Barry - Maxfield - Schneider - O'Keefe

just have to find a replacement for Benny (hmmm wonder if Mark Browning could make a comeback???)