Best Swans Team Since They Moved To Sydney

[swansrule100]

I have exams at the moment and was stuck here printing uni notes... so decided to pick a team of best players since the swans moved to sydney cos thats how long ive been watching.. its rushed so probably left out a lot of players id like in :P

B: Andrew Schuable, Andrew Dunkley, Stevie Wright
HB: Dennis Carroll, Paul Roos, Mark Bayes
C: David Murphy, Greg Williams, Wayne Schwass
HF: Dale Lewis, Barry Hall, Stuart Maxfield
F: Adam Goodes, Tony Lockett, Michael Oloughlin
Foll: Barry Round, Daryn Cresswell, Paul Kelly (c)

Int (from) Gerard Healy, Greg Stafford, Rod Carter, Bernard Toohey, Jude Bolton, Brett Kirk, Leo Barry,


yeh its rushed...and pointless sorry will anyone actually care :P
it put off study tho

[NMWBloods]

Healy at HFF and Lewis on the bench.

Tony Morwood on the other HFF and Maxfield on the bench.

Stevie Wright was a forward and rover, not a back pocket.

[Plugger46]

Schaubs would not be in my side.

[Rob-bloods]

Good discussion points!

Healy for Schwass, Toohey would have to be in the defence, Morwood for Lewis, Carter would have to get a guernsey for Schaubs. Agree re Stevie Wright with NMWBloods, forward or interchange.

Kickett, Ackerley, Bernie Evans, Browning, Paul Williams would have to be considered. Moose Henwood too use we lack characters in this collection.

Personally Stafford, Jude, Schaubs, Lewis would not make it.

Who would coach? I suggest Spanner Spence who was an assistant under Tom Hafey!

Now how about the worst in no particular order!

My suggestions Allison Gaspar Taubert Picken Daffy Bomford Doolan Nettlebeck Russell.

Coach Buckenara - Assistant Col Kinnear

[GoBloods]

my team would be
b. b.toohey a.dunkley d.carroll
hb. m.neagle p.roos m.bayes
c. d.murphy g.williams w.schwass
hf. t.morwood b.hall m.oloughlin
f. wcapper. t.lockett s.wright
r. b.round g.healy p.kelly
int. m.browning d.creswell a.goodes b.mitchell p.hawke d.lewis s.maxfield

[The Boot]

Most posters will be too young to remember, but years ago - possibly the early 80s, there was a computer generated fight between Muhammad Ali & Rocky Marciano.

http://www.jjhuddle.com/discus/messages/36114/210979.php

Anyhow, years after one dying and the other retiring this thing was put together to see who would really have won a ding-dong between them.

Imagine if the same thing could be done with this "best of" team in this thread.

Whoo .. loogout!!!

[liz]

Originally posted by GoBloods
int. m.browning d.creswell a.goodes b.mitchell p.hawke d.lewis s.maxfield

Paul Williams has won two B&F out of three completely seasons at the club. Unless you're counting him out on the basis of not enough time spent at the club, surely he'd get a guernsey ahead of someone like Lewis?

[Nico]

Originally posted by lizz
Paul Williams has won two B&F out of three completely seasons at the club. Unless you're counting him out on the basis of not enough time spent at the club, surely he'd get a guernsey ahead of someone like Lewis?

Merv Neagle, Gerard Healy and Paul Williams would not even ask Steve Wright to carry their bags.

[Captain]

My team:

Capper Lockett Goodes
O'Laughlin Hall Bayes
Murphy G Williams Cresswell
Carrol Roos Schwass
Bayes Dunkley Toohey
Round Kelly Healy
Mitchell Morwood P Williams Wright
Emer: Stafford Maxfield Carter

Shannon Grant would have been in my team had he stayed, though he has played his best footy with the Roos.

Luffy - Would be interesting to see your best team, from an ex players point of view and someone still around the club.

[NMWBloods]

Originally posted by Nico
Merv Neagle, Gerard Healy and Paul Williams would not even ask Steve Wright to carry their bags.

Now Merv Neagle - there was a seriously classy player. Sheedy was talking about highly talented players he had coached the other week, only named 2 or 3, and included Neagle.

[SwansRock]

lala

myn would be Jude Bolton

[swansrule100]

Now how about the worst in no particular order!.....

i saw this is one of the posts and still bored with exams so heres my most disapointing swans team since they moved to sydney

B: Malakallis, Mcgovern, Athorn
HB: Mckellar, Dion Scott, J.Crawford
C: Neesham, Bomford, Tingay
HF: Osborne, Brereton (c), Siddons
F: Werner, Hutton, Capper (1991 version he couldnt kick 30m)
FOLL: Cole, Howldsworth, Atkins
Int: (from) B.Green, Rocca, Fell, Daffy, Allison

[Bart]

Originally posted by swansrule100
Now how about the worst in no particular order!.....

i saw this is one of the posts and still bored with exams so heres my most disapointing swans team since they moved to sydney

B: Malakallis, Mcgovern, Athorn
HB: Mckellar, Dion Scott, J.Crawford
C: Neesham, Bomford, Tingay
HF: Osborne, Brereton (c), Siddons
F: Werner, Hutton, Capper (1991 version he couldnt kick 30m)
FOLL: Cole, Howldsworth, Atkins
Int: (from) B.Green, Rocca, Fell, Daffy, Allison

This exercise is pointless unless we set some standard, as in must have played x games.

Daffy played 1 match. Tingay didn't even get to play one. Jeez Rocca looked good in the few matches he did play for us.

Ah Brent Green. Dolph Lundgren lookalike.

[swansrule100]

sorry they are just players who annoyed me... and it beats studying for exams

[sharpie]

Hang on. You cant have a worst team without mentioning Donkey Myles. I take it personally that he was allowed to wear the red and white. Damn he was hopeless.