If Only?

[swansrule100]

All the talk of bolton or hayes made me think if the swans could have any one player from another team who would everyone take??

personally i think we need a defender so someone like scarlett even.. but then u got some champion midfielders and forwards i guess..
i dont have an answer myself..
prolly no one will reply anyway :P

[timthefish]

leppitsch.

[bloodboy]

Nick Riewoldt

What a gun this kid is. He is definitely the one player I would pick. We have stolen many a St. Kilda gun player in the past so who knows...?

[treespirit]

The hottest young ruckman, whoever he is.

[ScottH]

Chris Judd.

[Go Swannies]

We need to be grooming another full forward. Last week at this time I was despairing as I thought Baz would get nailed on hearsay and old reputation. I could not think of any way to structure our forward line without him. Mickey is too fragile, Davis, Pebbles and Schneider too small. Nicks has done a geat job but as support for Baz. If Baz was injured how could we construct a winning forward line right now?

I think we have one of the most potent forward lines in the AFL. But, even when he's not kicking well, you need to have Baz, Plugger, Lloyd or the like there as the gathering point. We seem to have several options for ruckman (good thing too!) including Ball, Doyle, MJ, LRT. But no back-up for Baz. Any ideas who could evolve into that role over the next few years - or do we need to recruit someone?

[sharpie]

Sam Mitchell.

We have the forwards.

With Schauble and Goodes both on the park, we have the defenders

We have the outside midfielders.

But this guy extracts more ball from ruck contests than anyone else I can think of running around at the moment.

[Bleed Red Blood]

Judd.

[hammo]

Judd, Pavlich or Reiwolt

[NMWBloods]

Simon Black.

[Schneidergirl]

Vossy.... Mal Michael.... Leppitsch...

[stellation]

I would take any of
Chris Judd
Matthew Pavlich
Simon Black

in that order. If I was a little more sensible and actually went for what I think the team needs right now I would probably switch it to

Chris Judd
Simon Black
Sam Mitchell

in that order.

[SwansRock]

i dunno

i can't really think of anyone

[swansrule100]

if i went for a midfielder it would be simpson... he gets so much of it and uses it well

if i wanted a forward id get brown from brisbane he is young and plain awesome

and a defender id prolly go for leppitsch

and a ruckman everitt... tho ruck is not that vitalfor us we have good ruckmen

[SwansRock]

mm

maby Voss from lions but would you have to swap a player we already have cause i wouldn't wanna do that