My Pick at TOTC

Collapse
X
 
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts
  • robbieando
    The King
    • Jan 2003
    • 2750

    My Pick at TOTC

    B. Fred Goldsmith Rod Carter David Ackerley
    HB. John Rantall Ron Glegg Dennis Carroll
    C. Herb Matthews Greg Williams David Murphy
    HF. Peter Bedford Laurie Nash Tony Morwood
    F. Tony Lockett Bob Pratt Roy Cazaly
    Fol. Barry Round Bob Skilton (C) Paul Kelly
    Int. Graham Teasdale Jim Cleary Ricky Quade Mark Tandy
    Emg. Barry Mitchell Gerard Healy Austin Robertson
    Once was, now elsewhere
  • Jimmy C
    On the Rookie List
    • Jan 2003
    • 366

    #2
    I like your list. Pretty safe and non-inflammatory.

    I don't know why, but the only player I'm unsure about is Quade.

    I've always that that Rhys-Jones could find a spot somewhere (or Mark Browning?).

    I've never forgiven Barry Mitchell for that shepherd he put on Swans players (as a Carlton runner) a couple of seasons ago (the absolute treachery).

    Who's yr Coach? Is PK the VC (that would be my suggestion)?

    Comment

    • robbieando
      The King
      • Jan 2003
      • 2750

      #3
      Kelly of course is the vice-captain, However it wouldn't surprise me if the club names co captains. I think they want to have a captain who represents both eras of the club so Co Captains might be the go.

      Jack Bissett as the coach only because of the fact he coached us to a flag and a Grand Final in the other years.

      Rhys-Jones wasn't norminated

      Vic Blecher and Mark Browning are unlucky

      Still I'am about to make a change. Look below
      Once was, now elsewhere

      Comment

      • robbieando
        The King
        • Jan 2003
        • 2750

        #4
        B. Fred Goldsmith Rod Carter David Ackerley
        HB. John Rantall Ron Glegg Dennis Carroll
        C. Herb Matthews Greg Williams David Murphy
        HF. Peter Bedford Laurie Nash Tony Morwood
        F. Tony Lockett Bob Pratt Roy Cazaly
        Fol. Barry Round Bob Skilton (C) Paul Kelly(VC)
        Int. Graham Teasdale Jim Cleary Mark Tandy Vic Belcher
        Emg. Barry Mitchell Gerard Healy Austin Robertson Ricky Quade

        Coach: Jack Bissett
        Once was, now elsewhere

        Comment

        • robbieando
          The King
          • Jan 2003
          • 2750

          #5
          Here is Matt Burgan's team, **** I reckon

          South Melbourne/Sydney Team of the Century

          B: Jim Dorgan, Fred Goldsmith, Vic Belcher
          HB: John Rantall, Ron Clegg, Dennis Carroll
          C: Herb Matthews Snr, Greg Williams, Jim Caldwell
          HF: Peter Reville, Laurie Nash, Peter Bedford
          F: Roy Cazaly, Bob Pratt, Tony Lockett
          FOLL: Barry Round, Paul Kelly, Bob Skilton
          I/C: Jack Graham, Len Mortimer, Mark Tandy, Gerard Healy
          EMG: Jim Cleary, Bruce Sloss, Terry Brain, Billy Williams

          Coach: Jack Bisset
          Captain: Bob Skilton
          Vice-Captain: Paul Kelly
          Once was, now elsewhere

          Comment

          • tez
            Warming the Bench
            • Jan 2003
            • 251

            #6
            Robbie,
            I see you have included Austin Robertson. Is that senior
            or junior as I think both played for Sth Melb?

            Comment

            • SWANSBEST
              On the Rookie List
              • Jan 2003
              • 868

              #7
              Surely it would be SNR . Dad was a star while JNR was a good player
              WMP

              Comment

              • tez
                Warming the Bench
                • Jan 2003
                • 251

                #8
                Ok, Found it now, Robertson snr

                Comment

                • Foreign Legion
                  Senior Player
                  • Feb 2003
                  • 3368

                  #9
                  Digging this thread up again - I thought I'd have a go...

                  FB Belcher Goldsmith Bayes

                  HB Browning Clegg Rantall

                  C Matthews Williams Caldwell

                  HF Morwood Nash Bedford

                  FF Kelly Pratt Lockett

                  Rucks Round Healy Skilton

                  Int Carroll, Carter, Graham, McLeish

                  Emerg Teasdale, O'Loughlin, Mortimer, Cresswell

                  Note: Nash and Clegg could swap positions and the Fullback position could go to Carter instead. I also reckon Graham could be the first Ruck.

                  An old South supporter has told me many times that Ron Clegg was the only players he has seen that was just about as good as "The Chimp"!

                  Cheers.

                  Comment

                  Working...