12 players...

[Cheer Cheer]

From our team would fit into any other AFL team according to Mick Malthouse.
I bring this up because I remember a similiar topic about who from our team would make it into other AFL teams, and people struggled to name them.
I'll start the ball rolling on the 12 I reckon he is talking about (from last night) : -

Hall
O'loughlin
Goodes
Williams
Saddington
Maxfield
Kennelly
Schnieder

Maybe the Brisbane Lions excluded...

[Reggi]

Better question

Would McGough, Molloy, B Holland, B Johnstone, Mckee get a game in any other side?

[Cheer Cheer]

Dont forget josh fraser and jason cloke

[NMWBloods]

Re: 12 players...

I bring this up because I remember a similiar topic about who from our team would make it into other AFL teams, and people struggled to name them.{snip}
Maybe the Brisbane Lions excluded...

The previous thread was specifically about the Lions, in which case I reckon only a couple of those would make it. But I agree that these would get games in most other sides.

The others could be:
Davis
Ball
Crouch
C Bolton
J Bolton

[Reggi]

Josh Fraser has modelled his game style and look on the cartoon character 'Goofy'.

Could still come good - hasn't shown much thus far

[Cheer Cheer]

I think josh is only going to get worse. He has had a steady downfall since his good first year, and each year is going down. this year the trend continues, maybe he needs a change of club, but I dont want him.

[Nico]

3AW commentators in Melbourne are having a love affair with Josh Fraser.

They all say he is a great talent who is still developing and will be a key position player. Talk to footy fans down here and most say he is grossly over rated.

My observations last night were that he is soft, has little pace, knows little about defensive play and doesn't like the hard stuff.

He seemed lost and gave his sde nothing.

[Charlie]

Hall
Davis
Williams
Maxfield
Doyle
Kennelly
O'Loughlin
Saddington
Ball
Crouch
Schneider
Goodes

They'd be the twelve that most clubs would want to pick from, given the choice. Although, I'd be worried if ANY club didn't have 12 players who could comfortably slot into any other side... considering how even the comp is designed to be.