Roos - no changes

[Captain]

Originally posted by NMWBloods
We're taking an injured player and a hack into the game. Great!!

When you think about it, we don't have any standouts that would come in for these two (assuming you are referring to Bevan and Williams).

Vogels would be my choice if any.

I guess Malceski could come in for Bevan though it is marginal whether he would have more of an impact.

The other is Schauble. He would come in more as a backup which in itself is a worrying sign.

[Snowy]

Emerg. Schauble, Malceski and Vogles. Willo hasn't flown to Melbourne with the team.

[Go Swannies]

Originally posted by Snowy
Willo hasn't flown to Melbourne with the team.

????

[DST]

Originally posted by NMWBloods
We're taking an injured player and a hack into the game. Great!!

The Saints are taking 3 injured players in and are playing Fiora plus Stone on the emergency list to come in.

If ever we are going to beat St Kilda this is the game.

DST

[DST]

Originally posted by Snowy
Emerg. Schauble, Malceski and Vogles. Willo hasn't flown to Melbourne with the team.

That would suggest he is still getting constant treatment on his thigh.

Probably best to give him another day without a flight and continue to have him iced and rubbed down before flying tomorrow morning.

DST

[Snowy]

On the later news bulletin they suggested that he flew down separately this morning. Doubt Bevan would be left out.

[Newbie]

Originally posted by Jeffers1984
Bevan's in to knock out a few blokes, get suspended and let Moore, Mcveigh or Malceski play in the final.

I need Bevan just needs to knock mcguire out and he is done for the night. Just need to test his hip injury out. One big tackle and Bevan has done his job.

[NMWBloods]

I'd like to see Bevan crunch Ball, Milne and finally Maguire in some barely legal or illegal (the latter more likely for Bevan) tackles.

[ScottH]

Originally posted by DST
That would suggest he is still getting constant treatment on his thigh.

Probably best to give him another day without a flight and continue to have him iced and rubbed down before flying tomorrow morning.

DST

I think they said he flew in yesterday!!!

[ugg]

Strange decision considering St Kilda's defensive problems. Vogels would have stretched their defence that bit more.

[SXP]

Originally posted by ugg
Strange decision considering St Kilda's defensive problems. Vogels would have stretched their defence that bit more.

Perhaps, but I think Roos is worried about their midfield. He's got enough firepower in the forward line without Vogels.

[NMWBloods]

I don't think Bevan adds anything to the midfield.

[SXP]

Originally posted by NMWBloods
I don't think Bevan adds anything to the midfield.

He, he, maybe he's our suprise package...

[Foreign Legion]

Yes he is a suprise package - he will surprise most of us if he does well.

Still, the one thing Bevan has is G&D, if he displays this as much as possible he may be handy.

My pick for B.O.G. if the Swans win - Adam Goodes or Craig Bolton.

THEY are the key players for me.
.....I'm assuming Bolton will play on Riewoldt.

[punter257]

but he's courageous and tackles well

but seriously if he plays i hope he does alright and adds something to the team