Round 6 Tips

[shearer]

ECE
Saints
Penno
Wests

[KangaCoach]

CAMPBELLTOWN
EASTCOAST
WESTS
ST GEORGE

[Whopper]

East Coast
St George (by 10 goals)
Penno
Wests

[ash]

tips ash

ECE by 70
St George by 21
Penno by 36
Wests by 13

[BeeEmmAre]

Leaderboard after round 6.

20 Johnno74 (3)
19 Roo (3)
18 Kanga Coach (2)
18 Oscar (3)
18 BeeEmmAre (3)
17 Woodsy (3)
17 Trouble (3)
17 Whopper (3)
16 Monty Burns2 (2)
16 Northern Swan (3)
16 Joe Dirt (3)
16 Norris Lurker (3)
15 Pekay (2)
15 Coastal Boy (2)
15 North Shore Angel (3)
15 Humphrey Bear (3)
15 Rafters (3)
14 I_Heart_Kefalas (2)
14 Shearer (3)
13 Junior (3)
12 Big Al (2)
12 William Wallace (2)
12 The Hobbit (3)
11 One More Crack (2)
10 Habib (2)
10 Ash (3)
9 MSA Benny (2)
8 Tiger Cub (2)

I had no idea what to do with the score wiping fiasco at Gore Hill Oval, given that St George actually scored more points than North Shore.
So for tipping purposes only I declared it a draw and gave everyone one point.
However, I have a record of all those who tipped North Shore and if there is overwhelming support for the match to be scored as a Bombers' win, then the figures will be updated.
I look forward to finding out your opinions on this.

[Norris Lurker]

North Shore won the game, so I think it should be declared a North Shore win for tipping purposes. I'll lose a point for that, because I tipped St George, but if North Shore are the official winners then that should be our result.

[humphrey bear]

I agree with Norris.

I tipped Saints but North Shore got the 4 points and thats all that counts.

[Johno74]

I'm with Norris and the bear unfortunately

[NorthShoreAngel]

i tipped North Shore Bombers

[Rafters]

Like the TAB does, you need to pay out on the official results from the Sydney AFL - Norths got the 4 points from the match & should be acknowledged as winners in the tipping comp. For all we know the 19th player could have helped set-up the first 3 goals of the last quarter. Also, are we certain that it was only an extra player in the last quarter??

[shearer]

Rafters, the extra player was only an extra player for the first 7 minutes of the last quarter of which we kicked 2 goals. This extra player took no part in any of the play during that period.

Its our stuff up and we accept the rules and consequences of them.

[BeeEmmAre]

Seeing as it appears all correspondence is in favour of the tip being awarded to North Shore only, the leaderboard has been altered.

Leaderboard after round 6.

19 Johnno74 (2)
18 Roo (2)
18 Oscar (3)
17 Kanga Coach (1)
17 BeeEmmAre (2)
16 Woodsy (2)
16 Trouble (2)
16 Whopper (2)
15 Monty Burns2 (1)
15 Northern Swan (2)
15 Joe Dirt (2)
15 Norris Lurker (2)
15 North Shore Angel (3)
15 Rafters (3)
14 Pekay (1)
14 Coastal Boy (1)
14 Humphrey Bear (2)
13 I_Heart_Kefalas (1)
13 Shearer (2)
12 Junior (2)
12 The Hobbit (3)
11 William Wallace (1)
11 Big Al (1)
10 One More Crack (1)
10 Ash (3)
9 Habib (1)
8 MSA Benny (1)
7 Tiger Cub (1)