Final Four- Is It Enough????

Collapse
X
 
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts
  • rooboy
    Suspended by the MRP
    • Feb 2007
    • 247

    #46
    Monty are you & garns sitting together?

    Comment

    • Key Forward
      On the Rookie List
      • Jan 2007
      • 94

      #47
      Originally posted by rooboy
      Don't be shy Garns? its all in good fun?
      Sorry Rooboy, what was your question mate?
      Looking dangerous in the forward 50

      Comment

      • Key Forward
        On the Rookie List
        • Jan 2007
        • 94

        #48
        Originally posted by GoEagles
        The most ridiculous post yet.

        I could not name one competition in Victoria that has ten teams and only has a top 4. The top 4 provides no benefit for the top team and a top 5 rewards the top 3 teams and makes for a basic finals series.

        Its not about revenue its about providing teams, players and supporters the opportunity to participate in why we play the game.

        Get out of the 80's and dont be afraid to change for the better of the competition
        Finally you post somthing on here worth reading. I actually agree with you on this one.
        Looking dangerous in the forward 50

        Comment

        • KangaCoach
          On the Rookie List
          • Nov 2005
          • 189

          #49
          Originally Posted by GoEagles View Post
          The most ridiculous post yet.

          I could not name one competition in Victoria that has ten teams and only has a top 4. The top 4 provides no benefit for the top team and a top 5 rewards the top 3 teams and makes for a basic finals series.

          Its not about revenue its about providing teams, players and supporters the opportunity to participate in why we play the game.

          Get out of the 80's and dont be afraid to change for the better of the competition


          Thought you may be interested Diamond Valley FL (Div 1) in Vic is a 10 team comp that had a final four in 2006.
          On The Trail

          Comment

          • BeeEmmAre
            Commentary Team Captain
            • Aug 2005
            • 2509

            #50
            Originally posted by KangaCoach
            Thought you may be interested Diamond Valley FL (Div 1) in Vic is a 10 team comp that had a final four in 2006.
            And has just been taken over by Football Victoria I'm told.
            "It's up to the rest of the players in the room to make a new batch of premiership players next year," Adam Goodes, triple Bob Skilton Medallist, October 7, 2011.

            YOU BETCHA!!!!!!

            Comment

            • GoEagles
              On the Rookie List
              • Feb 2007
              • 107

              #51
              Originally posted by KangaCoach
              Originally Posted by GoEagles View Post
              The most ridiculous post yet.

              I could not name one competition in Victoria that has ten teams and only has a top 4. The top 4 provides no benefit for the top team and a top 5 rewards the top 3 teams and makes for a basic finals series.

              Its not about revenue its about providing teams, players and supporters the opportunity to participate in why we play the game.

              Get out of the 80's and dont be afraid to change for the better of the competition


              Thought you may be interested Diamond Valley FL (Div 1) in Vic is a 10 team comp that had a final four in 2006.
              Old supercoach to the rescue....

              And from my contacts down there they also want to change the final format to a top5.

              Surely you would agree Glenn?

              Comment

              • tara
                Senior Player
                • Aug 2005
                • 1514

                #52
                I read this and find it interesting that most accept a final 5 for a 10 team comp.

                Personally I would have top 5 for 12 team and top 4 for anything less.

                My reasons are simple, you are rewarding medicority for those that finish middle of the road.

                I hate that there is a final 8 for the AFL and would rather a final 6 but its not about footy to the AFL its about money. Im suprised we dont see a losers cup amongst the bottom half at the end of the year.

                Comment

                • Henry
                  On the Rookie List
                  • Jun 2004
                  • 69

                  #53
                  Originally posted by GoEagles
                  The most ridiculous post yet.

                  I could not name one competition in Victoria that has ten teams and only has a top 4. The top 4 provides no benefit for the top team and a top 5 rewards the top 3 teams and makes for a basic finals series.

                  SO you reckon that the AFL think their final 8 is stupid- That was the silliest call i have read on this website. Unless your name is Andrew i cant even comprehend that

                  Its not about revenue its about providing teams, players and supporters the opportunity to participate in why we play the game.

                  Get out of the 80's and dont be afraid to change for the better of the competition

                  Mate, I like a top 5 as well, but you mightn't realise the VAFA has been set up as 10 team divisions each playing a top 4 system forever and a day.

                  Comment

                  • GoEagles
                    On the Rookie List
                    • Feb 2007
                    • 107

                    #54
                    Originally posted by Henry
                    Mate, I like a top 5 as well, but you mightn't realise the VAFA has been set up as 10 team divisions each playing a top 4 system forever and a day.
                    And thats why it is an amatuer competition.

                    Perfect example

                    Comment

                    • Henry
                      On the Rookie List
                      • Jun 2004
                      • 69

                      #55
                      Originally posted by GoEagles
                      And thats why it is an amatuer competition.

                      Perfect example
                      It's off the topic, but you're dreaming mate. A-Grade Amo's is comfortably a better standard tham Sydney Premier League.

                      Comment

                      • GoEagles
                        On the Rookie List
                        • Feb 2007
                        • 107

                        #56
                        Originally posted by Henry
                        It's off the topic, but you're dreaming mate. A-Grade Amo's is comfortably a better standard tham Sydney Premier League.

                        Agree

                        Comment

                        • KangaCoach
                          On the Rookie List
                          • Nov 2005
                          • 189

                          #57
                          Originally posted by GoEagles
                          Old supercoach to the rescue....

                          And from my contacts down there they also want to change the final format to a top5.

                          Surely you would agree Glenn?
                          I don't think you will find many coaches who would take a final four over a final five in a 10 team comp!

                          It would mean that you could possibly win just over half your games and make the finals! I certainly wouldn't be arguing against the idea.

                          Although I do think a final four for 10 teams is fair enough and keeps clubs honest.
                          On The Trail

                          Comment

                          Working...