Do the Sydney AFL Top Ten's correspond with the team of the year nominees?

Collapse
X
 
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts
  • Offal
    Warming the Bench
    • May 2007
    • 173

    Do the Sydney AFL Top Ten's correspond with the team of the year nominees?

    PREMIER LEAGUE SENIORS TOP 10 PLAYERS
    After Round 17
    1. Declan Donohue (St George) 78
    2. Max Collett (UNSWES) 72
    3. Chris Lees (Campbelltown) 66
    4. Mark Egan (Sydney University) 63
    5. Billy Dixon (Balmain) 61
    6. Adam McConnochie (Wollongong) 60
    7. Matt Carey (Pennant Hills) 59
    7. Luke Jarjoura (UNSWES) 59
    9. Dane Rampe (UNSWES) 54
    10. Matt Withers (Western Suburbs) 53
  • BeeEmmAre
    Commentary Team Captain
    • Aug 2005
    • 2509

    #2
    Let's find out shall we.....

    Defenders Ranking Points
    Declan Donohue 1 78
    Luke Jarjoura 7 59
    Jon Bradfield 17 51
    Aaron Crisfield 19 49
    Ron Wason 20 46
    Chris Clareborough 30 39
    Chris Murphy 32 38
    Janis Blums 35 37
    Damian Bowles 35 37
    Daniel Lambert 35 37
    Tim Addison 45 34
    Medair Kassem 47 33
    Joel Carr 51 31
    Matt Edwins 62 28
    Jake Trestrail 68 27
    Mark Irving 72 26
    Alistair Richardson 77 24
    Brad Patterson 82 23
    Clint Wells 82 23
    Mark Maher 96 20
    Jay Karutz 100 19
    Adam Sutton 109 17
    Dan Wilson 124 15
    Marty Rodoreda 152 11
    Mitch Hogan 168 9

    Midfielders Top 10 ranking Top 10 points
    Max Collett 2 72
    Chris Lees 3 70
    Mark Egan 5 63
    A McConnochie 6 60
    Matt Carey 7 59
    Luke Jarjoura 7 59
    Daniel Napper 9 57
    Ben Attwood 10 56
    Frank Punch 11 55
    Alex Goodall 12 54
    Lachlan Pryor 13 54
    Shane Ryan 16 52
    Peter Kefalas 17 51
    Jon Vlatko 22 43
    Michael Dombroski 23 42
    Ben Sutton 23 42
    Chris Noordhof 25 41
    Dwain Watkins 25 41
    Luke Stanford 28 40
    Brandt Jack 41 35
    Mark Skuse 45 34
    Jason Coulloupas 57 29
    Shanan Kershaw 57 29
    David Linsen 57 29
    Steve Wilsen 62 28
    Alistair Richardson 77 24
    Eid Kassem 90 21
    Stephen Hudson 100 19
    Evan Davis 109 17
    Scott Richmond 109 17
    Shane Davis 146 12
    Peter Carey 181 8

    Forwards Top 10 ranking Top 10 points Goals
    Brad Abbott 41 35 87
    Peter Dugmore 68 27 75
    Chris Lees 3 70 31
    Matt Carey 7 59 19
    Dane Rampe 12 54 16
    Matt Withers 15 53 32
    Ron Wason 20 46 26
    Alex Lee 21 44 59
    Matt Eurell 32 38 68
    Gus Seebeck 32 38 56
    Troy Luff 35 37 41
    Troy Bartlett 41 35 24
    Michael Healy 61 28 12
    Kieran Wright 61 28 22
    Daniel Kulk 68 27 37
    Ben Rogers 90 21 52
    Clint Setford 90 21 38
    Nick Campbell 157 10 49
    Ryan Officer 181 8 41

    Rucks Top 10 ranking Top 10 points
    Billy Dixon 4 68
    Josh Leary 41 35
    Max Wilson 51 31
    Ash Condon 72 26
    Mitch Frail 82 23
    Edward Wilson 82 23
    Angus Darling 90 21
    Michael Holmes 90 21
    Bill Lafferty 96 20
    Tom Heath 157 10

    The only change I make is I guarantee selection for the top two goalkickers, which means, after 18 rounds and using the criteria, my team would be:

    B: (rck) Josh Leary (def) Ron Wason (def) Aaron Crisfield
    HB: (def) Declan Donohue (def) Jon Bradfield (mid) Max Collett
    C: (mid) Matt Carey (mid) Daniel Napper (mid) Ben Attwood
    HF: (mid) Chris Lees (fwd) Peter Dugmore (fwd) Dane Rampe
    F: (mid) Mark Egan (fwd) Brad Abbott (fwd) Matt Withers
    FOLL: (rck) Billy Dixon (mid) Luke Jarjoura (mid) Adam McConnochie
    INTER: Frank Punch, Alex Goodall
    Lachlan Pryor, Shane Ryan
    EMERG: Peter Kefalas Alex Lee Jon Vlatko

    The interchange and emergencies are the next seven players in order of the top 10 list.
    With over 50 goals each Alex Lee and Ben Rogers should probably be in over Withers and Rampe, but the rest I'm happy with.
    The changes from last week were: Attwood swaps with Pryor between wing and interchange, and Kefalas replaces Sutton in the emergencies.
    Last edited by BeeEmmAre; 27 August 2008, 08:15 PM. Reason: Updated after round 18.
    "It's up to the rest of the players in the room to make a new batch of premiership players next year," Adam Goodes, triple Bob Skilton Medallist, October 7, 2011.

    YOU BETCHA!!!!!!

    Comment

    • Offal
      Warming the Bench
      • May 2007
      • 173

      #3
      More proof that your TOp 10 system is flawless BMR.....well played...

      Comment

      • bencadian
        On the Rookie List
        • Dec 2005
        • 7

        #4
        would have rogers in forward pocket

        Comment

        Working...