Southern Power going backwards?

Collapse
X
 
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts
  • The Late Mail
    On the Rookie List
    • Nov 2009
    • 47

    Southern Power going backwards?

    The Southern Power have announced Simon Closter as Senior Coach again.

    Makes you wonder how many chances a guy can get to jag a premiership. I would have thought they would go in a different direction after the failed finals campaign and ordinary 2008. It seems like Jason Philp left them with a Grand Final team in 2007 and they've gone backwards under Closter despite the roster being the same or better.

    My mail is several fringe St George players will play with the Power next year as they don't want to play against them - and get flogged.

    The Dragons v Power Div 2 games will be a good local derby next year.
  • tara
    Senior Player
    • Aug 2005
    • 1514

    #2
    Originally posted by The Late Mail
    The Southern Power have announced Simon Closter as Senior Coach again.

    Makes you wonder how many chances a guy can get to jag a premiership. I would have thought they would go in a different direction after the failed finals campaign and ordinary 2008. It seems like Jason Philp left them with a Grand Final team in 2007 and they've gone backwards under Closter despite the roster being the same or better.

    My mail is several fringe St George players will play with the Power next year as they don't want to play against them - and get flogged.

    The Dragons v Power Div 2 games will be a good local derby next year.

    Might also have had a bit to do with the lack of games they had under their belts coming into the finals given the number of teams who could be bothered showing up against them.

    Comment

    • Tom Wills
      Warming the Bench
      • May 2008
      • 478

      #3
      Originally posted by The Late Mail
      The Southern Power have announced Simon Closter as Senior Coach again.

      Makes you wonder how many chances a guy can get to jag a premiership. I would have thought they would go in a different direction after the failed finals campaign and ordinary 2008. It seems like Jason Philp left them with a Grand Final team in 2007 and they've gone backwards under Closter despite the roster being the same or better.
      My mail is several fringe St George players will play with the Power next year as they don't want to play against them - and get flogged.
      Late Mail, Interesting post. You start off sledging the coach and finish with them recruiting new platers to the club?

      Comment

      • Tom Wills
        Warming the Bench
        • May 2008
        • 478

        #4
        OK... meant to type players...not platers.

        Comment

        • shearer
          Regular in the Side
          • Jan 2003
          • 673

          #5
          My mail is several fringe St George players will play with the Power next year as they don't want to play against them - and get flogged.

          Thats gold, i seriously doubt that is the case.

          Comment

          • ShortHalfHead
            Senior Player
            • Dec 2008
            • 1024

            #6
            Originally posted by The Late Mail
            The Southern Power have announced Simon Closter as Senior Coach again.

            Makes you wonder how many chances a guy can get to jag a premiership. I would have thought they would go in a different direction after the failed finals campaign and ordinary 2008. It seems like Jason Philp left them with a Grand Final team in 2007 and they've gone backwards under Closter despite the roster being the same or better.

            My mail is several fringe St George players will play with the Power next year as they don't want to play against them - and get flogged.

            The Dragons v Power Div 2 games will be a good local derby next year.
            Is the 18's coach still around or did sanity prevail and he got banned for life?

            Comment

            • Hawknik
              On the Rookie List
              • Sep 2007
              • 186

              #7
              Originally posted by ShortHalfHead
              Is the 18's coach still around or did sanity prevail and he got banned for life?
              Was only thinking this last week, we have heard not a whisper of any sanctions etc out of that since it occurred.....

              Comment

              • tara
                Senior Player
                • Aug 2005
                • 1514

                #8
                Originally posted by Hawknik
                Was only thinking this last week, we have heard not a whisper of any sanctions etc out of that since it occurred.....
                I heard that he has no case to answer.

                Comment

                • Bert
                  On the Rookie List
                  • Apr 2007
                  • 110

                  #9
                  No case to answer?

                  Comment

                  • tara
                    Senior Player
                    • Aug 2005
                    • 1514

                    #10
                    He didnt send the guys out their to punch on - at the end of the day the suspensions handed out werent all that extreme given all you have to do is call an umpire a @@@@ to get two weeks.

                    Comment

                    • Hawknik
                      On the Rookie List
                      • Sep 2007
                      • 186

                      #11
                      Originally posted by tara
                      I heard that he has no case to answer.
                      This would imply either:
                      1) the afl investigated the issue and there were "no" witnesses
                      OR
                      2) the afl did not investigate and not one person put a complaint in

                      Either way, very poor for a full investigation not to occur considering the media it got, was juniors and was a GF.

                      Comment

                      • The Late Mail
                        On the Rookie List
                        • Nov 2009
                        • 47

                        #12
                        Originally posted by Hawknik
                        This would imply either:
                        1) the afl investigated the issue and there were "no" witnesses
                        OR
                        2) the afl did not investigate and not one person put a complaint in

                        Either way, very poor for a full investigation not to occur considering the media it got, was juniors and was a GF.
                        According to the Southern Power website, the coach has not been reappointed.

                        Comment

                        • george
                          On the Rookie List
                          • Oct 2010
                          • 1

                          #13
                          Southern Power going backwards?
                          The Southern Power have announced Simon Closter as Senior Coach again.

                          Makes you wonder how many chances a guy can get to jag a premiership. I would have thought they would go in a different direction after the failed finals campaign and ordinary 2008. It seems like Jason Philp left them with a Grand Final team in 2007 and they've gone backwards under Closter despite the roster being the same or better.
                          Cant go much further forward than they did this year........i suspect they'll be in finals contention in Div 1 next year!!

                          Comment

                          Working...