the best to play Sydney footy

Collapse
X
 
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts
  • justabaraker
    Regular in the Side
    • Jul 2012
    • 965

    the best to play Sydney footy

    It's a bit boring on this forum, especially for those of us who won't get invited to Pekay's wedding. Practice matches are still three weeks away, so I'm starting a discussion on who's the best player you've seen in Sydney footy.

    I'll start the ball rolling - I liked Armitage for Manly last season - in everything and the heart of a lion. And probably got Manly their premiership pretty much on his own shoulders.

    Going back a few years, Robbie Kerr for the Uni Eastern Bulldogs carried the team and went all day, all year, even when his teammates seemed to have had enough. He's now a major part of the Brisbane Lions coaching panel.

    Going way back, I was lucky enough to see Peter Ruskuklic for Easts who kicked 250 goals in a year and dominated - you can tell that you HAVE to be dominating to kick 250 plus goals in a year.


    Come on all you frustrated footy fans....give us some names.
  • saviour01
    Regular in the Side
    • Sep 2013
    • 932

    #2
    I've only been involved for 4 years but Rampe 2 years ago was absolute class.

    Comment

    • Footy Barista
      Warming the Bench
      • Nov 2013
      • 326

      #3
      Originally posted by justabaraker
      It's a bit boring on this forum, especially for those of us who won't get invited to Pekay's wedding. Practice matches are still three weeks away, so I'm starting a discussion on who's the best player you've seen in Sydney footy.

      I'll start the ball rolling - I liked Armitage for Manly last season - in everything and the heart of a lion. And probably got Manly their premiership pretty much on his own shoulders.

      Going back a few years, Robbie Kerr for the Uni Eastern Bulldogs carried the team and went all day, all year, even when his teammates seemed to have had enough. He's now a major part of the Brisbane Lions coaching panel.

      Going way back, I was lucky enough to see Peter Ruskuklic for Easts who kicked 250 goals in a year and dominated - you can tell that you HAVE to be dominating to kick 250 plus goals in a year.


      Come on all you frustrated footy fans....give us some names.

      I also like Armitage, however i doubt he was the only reason they won the comp...he didnt win best and fairest at the club and didnt win the Rod Podbury Medal so that there is a big call....Ranga Ediwickrama when he is on is an exception to watch as his best....its hard to say whose the best because so many players have come and gone....

      My particular favourite was Luke Jarjoura couple years back for the bulldogs, an absolute gun! the "three peat" east coast team had some good players too, the vlatko brothers, standford and even big gus seebeack alot of opposition clubs probably didnt rate him but he still managed to be a dominate force for years...

      Then you back to Nth Shore legend Livy, Tommy Hill, Crosby and Parker. Absolute legends.

      Comment

      • Mug Punter
        On the Rookie List
        • Nov 2009
        • 3325

        #4
        Originally posted by justabaraker
        It's a bit boring on this forum, especially for those of us who won't get invited to Pekay's wedding. Practice matches are still three weeks away, so I'm starting a discussion on who's the best player you've seen in Sydney footy.

        I'll start the ball rolling - I liked Armitage for Manly last season - in everything and the heart of a lion. And probably got Manly their premiership pretty much on his own shoulders.

        Going back a few years, Robbie Kerr for the Uni Eastern Bulldogs carried the team and went all day, all year, even when his teammates seemed to have had enough. He's now a major part of the Brisbane Lions coaching panel.

        Going way back, I was lucky enough to see Peter Ruskuklic for Easts who kicked 250 goals in a year and dominated - you can tell that you HAVE to be dominating to kick 250 plus goals in a year.


        Come on all you frustrated footy fans....give us some names.
        Rod Podbury for Bankstown/Campbelltown
        John Pitura for Norths

        Comment

        • Ken Oath
          Warming the Bench
          • Nov 2009
          • 117

          #5
          Jason Allie - SWS in the old league. Most gifted player I've still seen.

          Comment

          • Offal
            Warming the Bench
            • May 2007
            • 173

            #6
            Originally posted by justabaraker
            It's a bit boring on this forum, especially for those of us who won't get invited to Pekay's wedding. Practice matches are still three weeks away, so I'm starting a discussion on who's the best player you've seen in Sydney footy.

            I'll start the ball rolling - I liked Armitage for Manly last season - in everything and the heart of a lion. And probably got Manly their premiership pretty much on his own shoulders.

            Going back a few years, Robbie Kerr for the Uni Eastern Bulldogs carried the team and went all day, all year, even when his teammates seemed to have had enough. He's now a major part of the Brisbane Lions coaching panel.

            Going way back, I was lucky enough to see Peter Ruskuklic for Easts who kicked 250 goals in a year and dominated - you can tell that you HAVE to be dominating to kick 250 plus goals in a year.


            Come on all you frustrated footy fans....give us some names.
            Kippa from Balmain.

            Comment

            • Pekay
              Well retired, still sore
              • Sep 2004
              • 2134

              #7
              Originally posted by Ken Oath
              Jason Allie - SWS in the old league. Most gifted player I've still seen.
              Jason Allie had the X factor. Was so hard to not watch him and try to stop him!

              I never played higher than SFA besides 18s but watched a bit of SFL growing up.

              Manny Lynch at Wests was special.

              That Campbelltown team that went to play in the ACTAFL had some freaks in it.

              Ben Physick for longevity, started playing Seniors at 15 or 16, and as a bloke I grew up playing against and with for a short time, was good to see him win a flag.

              For SFA, and for his SFL days as well, Trev Burnett was a champion in every sense. Nice bloke off the field too.

              Shaun Edmunds at Parra as well, geez he was a tough bastard.

              Some of the blokes I had the (dis)pleasure of playing on like Fred David from Gong, Phil Cianci from Mac Uni, Andrew Browne from Sydney Uni, Andrew Davis & Thain from UTS were unstoppable, and the early days against Jacko from Manly, but the bloke was a @@@@@, personally. They were all match winners

              I reckon Don Ollington was up there too in the late 90s/2000s. Carter Mullins too. Loved playing on Jabba from Penrith, always a tough battle.

              We would get regularly flogged, so would normally see the opposition at their very best!

              Comment

              • Tim Freedman
                Warming the Bench
                • May 2008
                • 236

                #8
                I can only comment on the last 7-8 years of Sydney football but there have been many in my time.

                Brad "Superboot" Abbott was an amazing footballer and almost always kicked big bags. Didn't look like much but had hands like a vice and rarely missed a shot

                Ronnie Wason at North Shore is in the elite category of Sydney footballers in my opinion. Was a very difficult match up and no forward liked seeing him walk towards them. I remember speaking to Pete Dugmore about him and he said he was his toughest opponent by a mile

                Matty Withers is in a similar category to Wason. In his prime he was very good and his work ethic as a forward was second to none. It took a very good player to stop him

                Dane Rampe - its funny however I think that when he left he was just a "good" player that was better than average but nothing to plan against. When he returned he was a very different footballer and was elite. His time in the VFL certainly developed his all around game and he was a clear standout of the competition.

                Mike Beardsley was an outstanding footballer. An absolute professional who just accumulated possessions at will. A great stoppage player. We planned a lot against him when he was at the dogs for that year and actually used 2 players on him for the 2009 GF to nullify him. We were lucky enough to get him across for the 10-11 season where he played in those flags.

                In terms of East Coast - we had some very good players through that period. But Jamie Vlatko was the best forward I have seen play in Sydney by an absolute street. No one comes close to him in my biased opinion. He came straight from SANFL and just dominated the competition. You will never meet a more competitive person in sport. His brother Jon is pretty handy as well....

                Comment

                • Pmcc2911
                  Regular in the Side
                  • May 2013
                  • 516

                  #9
                  Good thread

                  Comment

                  • justabaraker
                    Regular in the Side
                    • Jul 2012
                    • 965

                    #10
                    Originally posted by Tim Freedman
                    In terms of East Coast - we had some very good players through that period. But Jamie Vlatko was the best forward I have seen play in Sydney by an absolute street. No one comes close to him in my biased opinion. He came straight from SANFL and just dominated the competition. You will never meet a more competitive person in sport. His brother Jon is pretty handy as well....
                    Only seen Jamie Vlatko a couple of times and he's worthy of a mention as a champion Baulko forward. But I was interested in FOOTY BARISTA's mention of big Gus Seebeck - couldn't run and couldn't even bend down to pick up the ball but wow, what a presence !
                    He just stands there in the ruck duel, or in the square, and dominates...opponents must sh+t themselves if they find that they are lined up against him.

                    Comment

                    • Norris Lurker
                      Almost Football Legend
                      • Jan 2003
                      • 2972

                      #11
                      That season Dane Rampe had a couple of years ago was something special - I've never seen one player dominate the league like he did that year.
                      But for a best player award, I'd be looking at someone who's the first picked in club and rep games, year in year out. I've been around for about 10 years, and the likes of Ron Wason and Declan Donohue fall into that category. If Barnaby Howarth hadn't been struck down in his prime, I'm sure he'd have been in that category as well.
                      Like Justabaraker mentioned, Gus Seebeck certainly had an imposing presence; especially the year he kicked the ton.

                      And a special mention for Luffy. Even after a long AFL career, when most former players would have been happy to give it away, he's had a very long stint in Sydney footy - 2 Phelan Medals, plenty of games, just about every accolade except a premiership medal.

                      Follow me on Twitter - @tealfooty

                      Comment

                      • cartman48
                        Warming the Bench
                        • Aug 2006
                        • 129

                        #12
                        Best I have seen in my time (Admittedly limited in the number of Premier games I've seen) are as follows:
                        Grant Bartholomaeus - Hard and skilful.
                        Sean Fitzpatrick - Talents Center Half Forward at Premier level and later in Div one as a player coach.
                        Jason Philp - Would have loved to have seen him in the Premier Division.
                        Carn the Southern Power.....

                        Comment

                        • Footy Barista
                          Warming the Bench
                          • Nov 2013
                          • 326

                          #13
                          Pekay - Would naming Thain (who played reserve grade in the weeks previous) have anything to do with him kicking 17 on you a few years ago whilst allegedly all "vaso'd" up? Rumour is he would have kicked well into the 20's had he come out for the last quarter

                          Comment

                          • Pekay
                            Well retired, still sore
                            • Sep 2004
                            • 2134

                            #14
                            Originally posted by Footy Barista
                            Pekay - Would naming Thain (who played reserve grade in the weeks previous) have anything to do with him kicking 17 on you a few years ago whilst allegedly all "vaso'd" up? Rumour is he would have kicked well into the 20's had he come out for the last quarter
                            OK, I will only claim 10 of those 17, as I was sent to the other end at half time after I'd been given a bath by him. Don't worry, I counted them all, he was getting great service and almost pulled the sun out of the sky had it not been overcast.

                            And, he had a smear of belt grip down one side of his guernsey, and a vasoline like substance down the other. He wouldn't tell me what it was, so I took a gob and rubbed it on his lips. Think it made him madder. Made our ressies laugh from upstairs though.

                            And it surprises me that he played reserves in the weeks previous, but so did I, two games a weekend for a few weeks there! But, we do what we have to with the limited numbers out here.

                            Regardless of how many he kicked on me, he was, in my opinion, a very talented forward, rarley missed a shot. Good for him.

                            Comment

                            • shearer
                              Regular in the Side
                              • Jan 2003
                              • 673

                              #15
                              the best to play sydney footy

                              Originally posted by justabaraker
                              It's a bit boring on this forum, especially for those of us who won't get invited to Pekay's wedding. Practice matches are still three weeks away, so I'm starting a discussion on who's the best player you've seen in Sydney footy.

                              I'll start the ball rolling - I liked Armitage for Manly last season - in everything and the heart of a lion. And probably got Manly their premiership pretty much on his own shoulders.

                              Going back a few years, Robbie Kerr for the Uni Eastern Bulldogs carried the team and went all day, all year, even when his teammates seemed to have had enough. He's now a major part of the Brisbane Lions coaching panel.

                              Going way back, I was lucky enough to see Peter Ruskuklic for Easts who kicked 250 goals in a year and dominated - you can tell that you HAVE to be dominating to kick 250 plus goals in a year.


                              Come on all you frustrated footy fans....give us some names.
                              Ruskuklic never kicked 250 in a season....it was only 213 haha. Blokes i know who played against him said he was a complete freak.

                              Best i played with: Tony Quinn,daylight then Clifty, Barts and Willo.

                              Matt Gibson was the toughest bloke i saw play in the SFL, never hit anyone high, late or on the cheap just very very hard at it.Plus won 3 b&f's in very good teams.

                              Best opponents: Podbury, Peter Robertson from Norths, (Full forward at Parramatta who kicked bags but cant think of his name, Keg Foster maybe?). Reid from Balmain.

                              Best player i coached: For talent Dugmore, if he played in the midfield he would of won 4 Phelans. Player i loved coaching, Stevey Wilsen.

                              Comment

                              Working...