AFL Sydney's Top 20 current players

Collapse
X
 
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts
  • justabaraker
    Regular in the Side
    • Jul 2012
    • 972

    AFL Sydney's Top 20 current players

    The Sydney AFL is running a countdown over the next few weeks or so of their selection of the best 20 present day players. We can vote on Facebook apparently, but I thought it might be a bit of fun to run it on this forum too.

    So come on Punters, give us some names.......
  • justabaraker
    Regular in the Side
    • Jul 2012
    • 972

    #2
    The ones who have caught my eye (all PD I'm afraid because that's all I've seen)...

    Edwins (Campbelltown)
    Hudson (Wests)
    Williamson (Wests)
    Conway (Wests)
    Kiel (UNSWES)
    Kefalas (UNSWES)
    Lycacis (StG)
    Killworth (StG)
    Wason (NS)
    Lee-Steers (NS)
    K Wright (Penno)
    Shepherd (Penno)
    Wray (Penno)
    Washington (Manly)
    Armitage (Manly)
    Brain (Manly)

    - - - Updated - - -

    The ones who have caught my eye (all PD I'm afraid because that's all I've seen)...

    Edwins (Campbelltown)
    Hudson (Wests)
    Williamson (Wests)
    Conway (Wests)
    Kiel (UNSWES)
    Kefalas (UNSWES)
    Lycacis (StG)
    Killworth (StG)
    Wason (NS)
    Lee-Steers (NS)
    K Wright (Penno)
    Shepherd (Penno)
    Goodall (Penno)
    Wray (Penno)
    Washington (Manly)
    Armitage (Manly)
    Brain (Manly)

    Comment

    • justabaraker
      Regular in the Side
      • Jul 2012
      • 972

      #3
      PS - how do you edit a post when you stuff it up ?

      Comment

      • saviour01
        Regular in the Side
        • Sep 2013
        • 932

        #4
        From us I was thinking Wynn, Killworth, Lycacis, Harry Green and Merson would have a good chance to make it. Dunno about someone like Donahue. But still, doubt we get 5 in the list. Will be dominated by Manly.

        Comment

        • often_confused
          Pushing for Selection
          • Mar 2014
          • 70

          #5
          On current results Saviour, I think 3 from Manly is a little light on. A couple that have stood out on my review would have to include:
          Brayden Fowler - leading goal kicker by about 20 from any one else.
          Connor Pettersson - must be in the votes in the Phelan
          Harry Koch - great game in Sydney Rep team
          David Stroud - Great rebound of half back
          Anthony Robertson - Goal kicking mid fielder
          Lachlan Kilpatrick - last years Rod Podbury medal winner, all class

          Of your other nominees, Alex 'Cheese' Goodall, and Kieran Wright are obvious choices as is Selby Lee-Steere. Elkington from Sydney Uni has played a few games in prem and looks hard to beat as a ruck that can go forward. Some of the St George talls are also imposing on their day, but maybe consistency is the issue. Several people on the list get a fair bit of ball but appear to have issues with decision making and skill execution. From the Town, I think it is more the runners like Etto or Peni that catch my eye.

          In the end it will be all in the eye of the beholder, and the selection criteria. Is it the 20 best or is it positional ? We could end up with 15 mid-fielders and five forwards all depending on the guide to selection. I do agree the side is likely to be dominated by Manly and would be surprised if all named above are not included.

          Comment

          • justabaraker
            Regular in the Side
            • Jul 2012
            • 972

            #6
            Good post, OftenC. I would "like" you if I could.
            You're right about the Manly domination though it will be more interesting to us all if there is a spread across the PD teams.
            I hope it's the 20 best rather than positional.

            But, more important, do you know how to edit a post that you have stuffed up ??
            Last edited by justabaraker; 21 June 2014, 01:01 PM. Reason: typo

            Comment

            • often_confused
              Pushing for Selection
              • Mar 2014
              • 70

              #7
              JB, after you have submitted a post and click on it one of the options is edit. I used that to correct a typo in my last post (though doubtless I missed others )

              ============

              I just undertook that process with this post and it may be that it is only permitted if it is done before another post follows it (you also appear to get options on emoticons like these
              Last edited by often_confused; 21 June 2014, 01:31 PM. Reason: checking

              Comment

              • justabaraker
                Regular in the Side
                • Jul 2012
                • 972

                #8
                Thanks again OC.....if only I could "like" you....
                Last edited by justabaraker; 21 June 2014, 07:27 PM. Reason: problem solved !

                Comment

                • often_confused
                  Pushing for Selection
                  • Mar 2014
                  • 70

                  #9
                  It is clear my predictions look pretty average at the moment. There appears to be a focus on those with interstate experience and Manly is clearly not dominating. It may be a little like the 'match of the week' and the decision makers have wanted to ensure everybody gets a mention or two. Or could Penno, St George and Manly come with a rush at the end

                  So far as I can see JB has 3 so far and saviour 1

                  Comment

                  • justabaraker
                    Regular in the Side
                    • Jul 2012
                    • 972

                    #10
                    Originally posted by often_confused
                    So far as I can see JB has 3 so far and saviour 1
                    Thanks for pointing this out OC - with friends like you, who needs enemies.......(just a light-hearted joke ok ?)
                    I expect that the final 8 will bring out the "true champs"....in other words, the ones I tipped !!

                    But having seen Manly last weekend, I could go along with your selections of Koch, Petterson and Fowler.
                    Interstate experience might be good on the CV of a SFL player, but I don't think it warrants their inclusion in the way that the SFL has done. But hey, there's always debate about selections like this and we wouldn't be footy lovers if we didn't all disagree.

                    Comment

                    • often_confused
                      Pushing for Selection
                      • Mar 2014
                      • 70

                      #11
                      We have completed 20 through to 6. Not sure how they are going to construct the top 5 but surely it must include:
                      Fowler - top goal scorer
                      Armitage - current medalist, consistent rep player
                      Goodall - consistent ball winner and Penno driving force
                      Pettersson - possibly best clearance player in the comp with Goodall
                      Selby L-S - carrying Northshore on his back this season

                      However, given my success rate so far I may be wrong, the obvious players to consider who would have been in my 20 would also include Wasson and Ranga (despite his injuries).

                      Any others that are viewed as MUST BE IN ?

                      Comment

                      • Tim Freedman
                        Warming the Bench
                        • May 2008
                        • 236

                        #12
                        I think some that could potentially be in the Top 5 are as follows:

                        Nick Ryan - St.George - one of the best forwards in the league IMO
                        Kieran Wright - Penno - I haven't seen too much of him this year but he was the premier backman for many years in the comp
                        Ranga - Penno - very elusive player and outstanding at his best -
                        Brayden Fowler - Manly - dominating the goal kicking this year and probably the first Manly player teams plan for in their pre game
                        Jeremy Kiel - UNSW - another one I haven't seen too much of this year but is a very underrated player in this comp
                        Evan Smith - Sydney Uni - I am unsure how this bloke doesn't play NEAFL every single week for Uni.
                        Selby Lee-Steere - North Shore - probably the best Utility player in the comp

                        Comment

                        • often_confused
                          Pushing for Selection
                          • Mar 2014
                          • 70

                          #13
                          TF, so that is 11 names and only 5 positions. All worthy, I guess that is what they want to generate debate and interest on Sydney footy and less observation on NEAFL, money distribution and all the things they get gripes about every week.

                          I imagine Goodall, Armitage and Fowler are a lock ... so maybe it is 8 names for 2 positions.

                          Comment

                          • saviour01
                            Regular in the Side
                            • Sep 2013
                            • 932

                            #14
                            What's that 4 from wests?

                            Only 1 from us, big game tomorrow.

                            But yeh, pretty much everyone on the list is interstate, few were playing their first season in sydney footy. You'd think Armitage and Fowler are locks.

                            Comment

                            • justabaraker
                              Regular in the Side
                              • Jul 2012
                              • 972

                              #15
                              Come on Punters....give it a name !!!!!!!!!!!

                              The top SFL player will soon be revealed, possibly tomorrow. Who will it be ?

                              Saviour, OftenC and I are liking Armitage (Manly) and I reckon we're looking good. TimF, who probably knows more about Sydney footy than all of us, likes Ryan, Ranga, Kiel, Wright or Evan Smith.

                              Give us ya last minute tips.

                              Comment

                              Working...