RWO Game Day Thread - Finals - August 30/31

Collapse
X
 
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts
  • Norris Lurker
    Almost Football Legend
    • Jan 2003
    • 2981

    RWO Game Day Thread - Finals - August 30/31

    FINALS


    Saturday 30th August

    Blacktown ISP
    9:00 Newtown Breakaways v Macquarie University Women?s Division One
    11:05 Sydney University v UNSW/ES Stingrays Women?s Division One
    13:10 Macquarie University v UTS Bats Division One
    15:30 Pennant Hills Demons v St George Dragons Premier Division

    Henson Park
    9:00 UTS Bats v Wollondilly Knights Division Four
    11:10 Randwick City v Saints Penrith Rams Division Three
    13:20 Sydney University v Blacktown Magic Division Two
    15:30 Wollongong Saints v Penrith Ramettes Women?s Division Two


    Sunday 31st August

    Blacktown ISP
    9:00 Penrith Rams v Macarthur Giants Under 19s Division Two
    11:05 UNSW/ES Bulldogs v Manly Warringah Giants Under 19s Division One
    1:10 Holroyd Parramatta Goannas v Pennant Hills Demons Division One
    15:30 Western Suburbs Magpies v Sydney University Premier Division

    Henson Park
    9:00 Nor-West Jets v Blacktown Magic Division Five
    11:10 Sydney University v UNSW/ES Bulldogs Division Four
    13:20 Nor-West Jets v Sydney University Division Three
    15:30 Western Suburbs Magpies v Manly Warringah Giants Division Two

    Follow me on Twitter - @tealfooty
  • saviour01
    Regular in the Side
    • Sep 2013
    • 932

    #2
    Thought the penno saints game was real even, could have gone either way. Interesting uni beat wests, did they bring many back from the neafl side?

    Comment

    • The Student
      Warming the Bench
      • Dec 2008
      • 281

      #3
      Originally posted by saviour01
      Thought the penno saints game was real even, could have gone either way. Interesting uni beat wests, did they bring many back from the neafl side?
      There were half a dozen blokes that might have played about 20 games of NEAFL between them this year. They'd predominantly played PD though.

      Comment

      • mountainsofpain
        Warming the Bench
        • Apr 2008
        • 266

        #4
        Originally posted by saviour01
        Thought the penno saints game was real even, could have gone either way. Interesting uni beat wests, did they bring many back from the neafl side?
        Looks like the flow through of players didn't stop at PD. Their Div 2 and Div 3 sides thrashed their opponents on the weekend.

        Also, Macarthur Giants yesterday turned up to their U19 Div 2 Semi-Final with only 15 players. A pretty poor look for the game.

        Comment

        • Norris Lurker
          Almost Football Legend
          • Jan 2003
          • 2981

          #5
          Originally posted by saviour01
          Thought the penno saints game was real even, could have gone either way.
          That game was a cracker. I'll have the article up this morning; but there were so many swings & roundabouts in that game. In the end it was Penno who fell over the line, but St George also put in an awesome effort.

          Follow me on Twitter - @tealfooty

          Comment

          • Footy Barista
            Warming the Bench
            • Nov 2013
            • 326

            #6
            Penno v Manly at Blacktown just like last years grand final should be a fantastic match next week.
            Interestingly I saw that Robertson from Manly played in the reserves after breaking his leg in May or June. They have been going fine without him but he's a big addition, even if he plays forward.

            Comment

            • Norris Lurker
              Almost Football Legend
              • Jan 2003
              • 2981

              #7
              This week's RWO Wrap of the weekend action is now online. Sorry I couldn't get it online last night - was in Melbourne yesterday & didn't get home till scandalously late.

              Follow me on Twitter - @tealfooty

              Comment

              • The Student
                Warming the Bench
                • Dec 2008
                • 281

                #8
                Originally posted by mountainsofpain
                Looks like the flow through of players didn't stop at PD. Their Div 2 and Div 3 sides thrashed their opponents on the weekend.
                It was more a function of having everyone available at this time of year. Looking at the team list, there were three or four players that had played a handful of PD games this season but had played an overwhelming majority of games in Div 2. Div 3 was a bit different in that they had five players that had played mainly Div 2 but as far as I understand they'll be unavailable this week due to our Div 2 team having the week off?

                Comment

                • ShortHalfHead
                  Senior Player
                  • Dec 2008
                  • 1024

                  #9
                  Originally posted by The Student
                  There were half a dozen blokes that might have played about 20 games of NEAFL between them this year. They'd predominantly played PD though.
                  Sam Sleigh played 9 NEAFL games and David Johnson 10. Not sure of the other four that played a game between them

                  Comment

                  • The Student
                    Warming the Bench
                    • Dec 2008
                    • 281

                    #10
                    Originally posted by ShortHalfHead
                    Sam Sleigh played 9 NEAFL games and David Johnson 10. Not sure of the other four that played a game between them
                    I didn't realize that those two had played so many games - I would have guessed half that. The actual total was 7 players who had a combined 35 NEAFL games (10, 9, 7, 5, 2, 1, 1). The composition of the team was probably not much different to most weeks.

                    Comment

                    • often_confused
                      Pushing for Selection
                      • Mar 2014
                      • 70

                      #11
                      As I understand the by-laws it is 6 games for the Club. For some reason the rule about playing 9 or more games at a higher level does not count if it is in a different competition. The NEAFL has a few byes so it is probably not hard to engineer the 6 Club Games required. As to it being in the spirit of the game ... that is an entirely different matter and SHH's observations make me concerned as to the Student's guesstimate.

                      In any event it will be a big ask to get over the Dragons this week ... not impossible but challenging. However the last three player numbers give it a clear ring of truth.
                      Last edited by often_confused; 1 September 2014, 04:34 PM. Reason: typo

                      Comment

                      • Pekay
                        Well retired, still sore
                        • Sep 2004
                        • 2134

                        #12
                        It's a disgrace, that's what it is. I don't mind losing a game, but when blokes who haven't played a game in that grade during the year can drop down a grade, the spirit of the game disappears. I'm glad I played my last game, but wish it was under different circumstances, like maybe playing the same side we played a few weeks back.

                        Comment

                        • tara
                          Senior Player
                          • Aug 2005
                          • 1514

                          #13
                          Originally posted by often_confused
                          As I understand the by-laws it is 6 games for the Club. For some reason the rule about playing 9 or more games at a higher level does not count if it is in a different competition. The NEAFL has a few byes so it is probably not hard to engineer the 6 Club Games required. As to it being in the spirit of the game ... that is an entirely different matter and SHH's observations make me concerned as to the Student's guesstimate.

                          In any event it will be a big ask to get over the Dragons this week ... not impossible but challenging. However the last three player numbers give it a clear ring of truth.
                          Would be interesting to see what the league think of it. Usually they say nothing unless an opposition club brings it to their attention.

                          As for the NEAFL games being considered higher I raised the issue with the league when it came to finals eligibility and the Giants and Div 2 under 19's. Its a grey area but even they admitted it would be pretty rich for a kid playing NEAFL to potentially drop back to div 2 19's.

                          As for team selections not being in the spirit of the game that exact type of manipulation cost my boys a spot in div 2 finals this year.

                          Comment

                          • The Student
                            Warming the Bench
                            • Dec 2008
                            • 281

                            #14
                            Originally posted by often_confused
                            As I understand the by-laws it is 6 games for the Club. For some reason the rule about playing 9 or more games at a higher level does not count if it is in a different competition. The NEAFL has a few byes so it is probably not hard to engineer the 6 Club Games required. As to it being in the spirit of the game ... that is an entirely different matter and SHH's observations make me concerned as to the Student's guesstimate.

                            In any event it will be a big ask to get over the Dragons this week ... not impossible but challenging. However the last three player numbers give it a clear ring of truth.
                            I have no idea what the selection strategy entails but I doubt that it would have been decided that the coaches would have worked it so that Johnson and Sleigh would qualify for PD finals by playing them on NEAFL bye weekends. We aren't smart enough to see that far ahead. I'm also unsure of the rules given that James Howard is ineligible but played 6 PD games?

                            Comment

                            • mountainsofpain
                              Warming the Bench
                              • Apr 2008
                              • 266

                              #15
                              Originally posted by Pekay
                              It's a disgrace, that's what it is. I don't mind losing a game, but when blokes who haven't played a game in that grade during the year can drop down a grade, the spirit of the game disappears. I'm glad I played my last game, but wish it was under different circumstances, like maybe playing the same side we played a few weeks back.
                              It's interesting that a side which finished fifth can win a crunch final over the third side by nearly 100 points.

                              I also watched some of the Div 2 match, and Sydney Uni were so far ahead of their opponents it wasn't funny.

                              Sydney Uni aren't going to worry about the spirit of the game when it comes to winning finals, clearly.

                              Maybe you need to talk to the League.
                              Last edited by mountainsofpain; 1 September 2014, 06:32 PM.

                              Comment

                              Working...