Team Selection: R19 v Adelaide at SCG

[longmile]

IN: Bice, Campbell, Mcdonald, Rosas
OUT: Kyle, Hamling, Hanily, Cleary (all omitted)

Our strongest team on paper all year IMO. Only really missing McInerney

[stevoswan]

In: Bice, Campbell, McDonald, Rosas

Out: H.Kyle (omitted), J.Hamling (omitted), T.Hanily (omitted), C.Cleary (omitted)

I like these changes.

[KSAS]

IN: Bice, Campbell, Mcdonald, Rosas
OUT: Kyle, Hamling, Hanily, Cleary (all omitted)

Our strongest team on paper all year IMO. Only really missing McInerney

And Wicks

[imuninformedtwo]

Bummed about the switch of Kyle and Bice. Don’t trust Bice against a high pressure, contest based team regardless of what he’s been doing in reserves. And don’t trust him down back, which is where he’s playing with that line up.

Let’s hope he proves me wrong.

[SwanSand]

As expected, we need to get the players we think are going to be our best 23 on the park and get them playing together.
The only other player who is missing other than Mcinerney is Wicks.
Knowing the selections from previous weeks - Cunningham will be dropped when Wicks returns. We need him in the backline, he is really important for our structure.
This then leaves us with the selection dilemma with Melican who may come in depending on the next 3 weeks results and how Rampe does.

Let’s stop the constant position changes and settle the team and players in their ideal spots except tactical changes within the game.

if we lose tomorrow, We have a real chance of losing the next 3 games and drop out of Top 2 but also Top 4. Next 3 games I would like to see the intent as it would be in September.

[imuninformedtwo]

IN: Bice, Campbell, Mcdonald, Rosas
OUT: Kyle, Hamling, Hanily, Cleary (all omitted)

Our strongest team on paper all year IMO. Only really missing McInerney

And Wicks.

[Thunder Shaker]

Also of interest is Adelaide adding ex-Swan Hall-Kahan to their team.

[longmile]

And Wicks

Knew I was forgetting someone

[Dow]

Interesting to see Melican is out of the VFL side injured

[Dow]

And Wicks.

I’d also argue Melican should be in for Rampe but that might just be my opinion

[Dow]

Bummed about the switch of Kyle and Bice. Don’t trust Bice against a high pressure, contest based team regardless of what he’s been doing in reserves. And don’t trust him down back, which is where he’s playing with that line up.

Let’s hope he proves me wrong.

To be fair Kyle has a future but he’s adding very little at the moment and we need more contributions to help us transition the ball out of defence

[KSAS]

Adelaide have both Tex and Laird our.

[imuninformedtwo]

To be fair Kyle has a future but he’s adding very little at the moment and we need more contributions to help us transition the ball out of defence

My view on Bice is with the contests he shirks and the times he runs over the ball, he’s often responsible for it being down there, or goals.

If his stint in twos has toughened him up and got him out of bad habits, cool. But I’m to be convinced.

[UUaswan]

Good MC.