Kirk.

[TheButcher]

Originally posted by Bart
You are right, what would we know ? And what would the mob thinking of who conferred these honours thinking of ?

Best and fairest 2005
2nd best and fairest 2003, 2004
4th Brownlow 2004
All-Australian 2004
International Rules Series 2003, 2004
Premiership side 2005
Captain 2006

Why can't you people handle the fact there are those who like Kirk and think he is the most gifted player to ever pull on the red and white and there are those who don't rate him.

It's life, get over it!

[Bart]

Originally posted by TheButcher
Why can't you people handle the fact there are those who like Kirk and think he is the most gifted player to ever pull on the red and white and there are those who don't rate him.

Sorry Butchie, I've missed something there. Can you clarify where I suggested this in my post

Originally posted by TheButcher
It's life, get over it!

Touche. Glad to see you have a sense of humour and are willing to have a joke at your own expense.

[ScottH]

Originally posted by TheButcher
Can i post my achievements from u/10 to u/16

they are better than kirks except i didn't get to play in a umm errr a "hybrid" game and i didn't get selected for a team that really plays no one.

I also was runner up to a few medals and got a few votes as well.

I must be a champion too!

Congratulations I didn't realise you'd been nominated in the top players in the Australia.


Your argument lacks any respectability.

[TheButcher]

Originally posted by ScottH
Congratulations I didn't realise you'd been nominated in the top players in the Australia.


Your argument lacks any respectability.

So does yours I am sorry. In fact most of your posts on RWO lack any substance.

[Bart]

Originally posted by TheButcher
Can i post my achievements from u/10 to u/16

they are better than kirks except i didn't get to play in a umm errr a "hybrid" game and i didn't get selected for a team that really plays no one.

I also was runner up to a few medals and got a few votes as well.

I must be a champion too!

Your family must be so proud

[ScottH]

Originally posted by TheButcher
Why can't you people handle the fact there are those who like Kirk and think he is the most gifted player to ever pull on the red and white and there are those who don't rate him.

It's life, get over it!

I don't think any one on here has ever stated he is the "most gifted player" etc.

But he was an important part of the team for the last few years, got himself a premiership medallion and a few accolades (for what they are worth) and most will admit his form has fallen off this year. Nothing unusual in that.

[Wardy]

Originally posted by ScottH
I don't think any one on here has ever stated he is the "most gifted player" etc.

But he was an important part of the team for the last few years, got himself a premiership medallion and a few accolades (for what they are worth) and most will admit his form has fallen off this year. Nothing unusual in that.

exactly - there are those who love him and there are those who dont - so lets leave it at that.

[Boodnutz]

Originally posted by TheButcher
Why can't you people handle the fact there are those who like Kirk and think he is the most gifted player to ever pull on the red and white and there are those who don't rate him.

It's life, get over it!

I've noticed that when someone's ill-thought-out comment gets rightly discounted, the writer of the ill-thought-out comment comes back with something over top to back his/her case. And normally (as in this case) it just sounds silly. Who says Kirk is the most gifted player ever to pull on the red and white? I certainly don't, but I do know he's dragged himself up by the bootlaces to be one the most effective players we've had in the past 10 years. And he's worthy of us cutting him some slack.

It's life? No, it's not. Life is what happens to you while you're busy making other plans.

[Wardy]

Originally posted by Boodnutz
It's life? No, it's not. Life is what happens to you while you're busy making other plans.

thank you John Lennon

[Boodnutz]

Originally posted by Wardy
thank you John Lennon

No worries. I'm just watching the wheels.

[Wardy]

Originally posted by Boodnutz
No worries. I'm just watching the wheels.

love it!!! Imagine all the people (on RWO) living life in peace!

[ScottH]

Originally posted by TheButcher
So does yours I am sorry. In fact most of your posts on RWO lack any substance.

I try not to abuse any substances.

[Boodnutz]

Originally posted by Wardy
love it!!! Imagine all the people (on RWO) living life in peace!

Which brings us back to Kirky - working class hero.

[TheButcher]

shudder.

[Wardy]

Originally posted by Boodnutz
Which brings us back to Kirky - working class hero.

Oh well agree to disagree I guess.