Your best 22 from years gone by...

[nomae]

Originally posted by ugg
M.Orchard R.O'Connor G.Bennett
M.Powell M.Kinnear L.Brockman
A.Bomford S.Tingay S.Russell
F.Campbell R.Fitzgerald B.Green
B.Piltz B.Wilson S.Feast
R.Mott N.Daffy S.McGlone (c)

J.Meiklejohn A.Rogers J.Thewlis D.Hunt

brilliant!
p.s. what ever happened to thewlis? he played one game and later that season we delisted him- why didnt we give him more of a shot?

[ugg]

He's at the Swans retirement farm aka South Adelaide. Was picked up by the Kangas on their rookie list last year but didn't play a game with them

[Gary]

Ackerley.......Dunkley............Barry
Bayes.........Roos.................Schwass
Kelly.......G.Williams...........Murphy
MOL......Hall..............P.Williams
Goodes......Lockett........Bedford
Teasdale.......Healy.........Skilton

Kirk....Carroll......T.Morwood....Wright

[NMWBloods]

I like that one, but I'd probably drop Kirk for Round.

I'd love to see Browning in there. I would consider swapping him for Schwass.

It's a tough choice between Dunkley and Carter.

[Gary]

Fair calls NMW...I really find it hard to place Kirk across the years given his weaknesses...but?

[shayne]

Where is Capper in the team? I know he was the main reason I started supporting the Swans when I was five

[hammo]

Originally posted by adnar
Why do people rate Luff as such a great player?

Very good question.

I think Luff must have done the skills coaching during the week based on the display in Geelong.

[Sanecow]

Originally posted by hammo
Very good question.

I think Luff must have done the skills coaching during the week based on the display in Geelong.

You are a total joke. A performance like that from the Swans and you choose to put the boot into, of all players, Troy Luff. Genius.

[gazza]

Originally posted by ugg
M.Orchard R.O'Connor G.Bennett
M.Powell M.Kinnear L.Brockman
A.Bomford S.Tingay S.Russell
F.Campbell R.Fitzgerald B.Green
B.Piltz B.Wilson S.Feast
R.Mott N.Daffy S.McGlone (c)

J.Meiklejohn A.Rogers J.Thewlis D.Hunt

good work ugg,some memorable long term stars in that lot.

recruiting dept. would be proud to read your team

[gazza]

based on 25 yrs in sydney that i have seen live.
each one in their best form.

ackerley carter dunkley
browning roos carroll
nagle g williams goodes
bayes hall t morwood
kelly lockett mitchell

round healy cresswell

i/c ball murphy o'loughlin rhys-jones

apologies to a lot of others who were close

[hammo]

Originally posted by Sanecow
You are a total joke. A performance like that from the Swans and you choose to put the boot into, of all players, Troy Luff. Genius.

It's just an opinion you clown. Not everyone agrees with your constant bagging of Kirk but they don't get abusive about it.

[Agent 86]

Originally posted by adnar
Why do people rate Luff as such a great player?

had a stand named after him when STILL playing.

[Sanecow]

Originally posted by swantastic
Isnt that Capper with hair like that?

1. Capper was never that pretty
2. Capper never made it that far into the defensive half.

[Sanecow]

Originally posted by hammo
It's just an opinion you clown. Not everyone agrees with your constant bagging of Kirk but they don't get abusive about it.

I only bag him when he kicks like a gimp or makes a smirking media appearance. It's not my fault it happens so often.

[swan_song]

Originally posted by adnar
Why do people rate Luff as such a great player?

Just watch your tongue young man.
Luffy is a deadset legend, just leave it at that. You can have the Lockett end at the Dome, but what other Swan has a stand named after him on the wing?
And besides, you never know who might read your post...if I were you I'd hate it if Luffy ever did, he might seek you out at the next aftermatch...