Tim Schmidt - NAB rising star?...

[Snake]

If Tim Schmidt doesn't get the NAB rising star for this weeks game, then there is something seriously wrong with the nomination process IMHO

[liz]

I suspect hype will dictate it goes to Hawkins at Geelong. To be fair to Hawkins, so it may well be more than hype. I know he kicked four goals, following on from three last week.

Schmidt was handy but not dominant. Normally a player needs to string a few of those performances together before they get a nomination.

[NMWBloods]

I would have thought Hawkins deserves it more.

[Jeffers1984]

If Schmidt plays a ripper next week against Adelaide, i'm sure he will get it then.

Hawkins this week easily.

[hammo]

The Tom-a-Hawk will win it this week and be the overall winner I'd suggest.

He looks a real gun.

[Snake]

I suspect hype will dictate it goes to Hawkins at Geelong. To be fair to Hawkins, so it may well be more than hype. I know he kicked four goals, following on from three last week.

Schmidt was handy but not dominant. Normally a player needs to string a few of those performances together before they get a nomination.

Strewth forgot about the tom-a-hawk.... Schmidt will get the nod soon me thinks....

[Danzar]

He got some possession and kicked two late goals but I thought his execution wasn't the best. He was pretty scrappy in some places, particularly his hand passes.

[stellation]

I thought he was pretty good for a guy who has played <10 games. I'm pretty sure he had a few clean disposals on the wing in front of us in the last quarter that impressed me, apart from the 2 goals.

[Jeffers1984]

Game was pretty scrappy all round anyways. Schmidty got some vital clearences and was at the right place for both of his goals.

Let's hope Moore gets a chance to find his feet in the seniors as well.

[ugg]

Some of his kicking was scrappy, but I would put that down to nerves. He is generally a good kick.

[Birdman]

The slowest player on the list.
Anyone see him give chase on in front of the members and get burnt by one of ours and a Lion? Has a big ass slowing him down...
Great hands in traffic and seems as though decision making will continue to improve.. not a bad possibility.

[Jeffers1984]

Hopefully he can be our own Sam Mitchell in the end. Big arsed accumulator/extractor of the ball who has a quick brain.

[Alibi Monday]

Brent Prismall (Gee) should get the nomination this week. 23 disposals 6 marks 3 goals

[goswannie14]

dad and I have both been impressed with his last 2 games, not only kicking goals, but at times being the link man in setting up scoring opportunities.

[bandwagon]

I was quite pleased with Schmidt's game, he certainly knows how to get his hands on the ball. But I wouldn't think he gets the nod, in fact can't think of many (any?) Swans nominations in the last 3-4 years.