AFL Top 10 players

[BeeEmmAre]

A belated start this year, but here are my Top 10 AFL players after round 4.

1. Daniel Kerr (West Coast) 30
2. Andrew McLeod (Adelaide) 29
3. Jimmy Bartel (Geelong) 28
3. Chris Judd (West Coast) 28
5. Gary Ablett (Geelong) 27
6. Scott Lucas (Essendon) 25
7. Simon Black (Brisbane Lions) 24
8. Brett Ebert (Port Adelaide) 23
9. Scott West (Western Bulldogs) 22
10. Tarkyn Lockyer (Collingwood) 21
10. Heath Shaw (Collingwood) 21
10. Matthew Pavlich (Fremantle) 21
10. Brent Harvey (Kangaroos) 21
10. Nick Dal Santo (St Kilda) 21

And the Swans are:

48. Amon Buchanan 11
48. Ryan O'Keefe 11
55. Peter Everitt 10
55. Barry Hall 10
55. Nick Malceski 10
73. Brett Kirk 9
73. Adam Schneider 9
89. Tadhg Kennelly 8
103. Craig Bolton 7
103. Jude Bolton 7
119. Darren Jolly 6
119. Ben Mathews 6
135. Nic Fosdike 5
179. Adam Goodes 2
194. Ted Richards 1

[swantastic]

What a surprise that no Swans in the top 10 but i would have thought that at (89. Tadhg Kennelly 8) would have been higher,as he has had a great start to the year.

[ScottH]

Can't beleive Ted is so far down the list of swans. He's been one of our most consistent players so far. Same with Kennelly and CBolton, they'd have to be my top 2 players so far this year.

Everitt has had one good game. and he rates higher??

[Chow-Chicker]

Can't beleive Ted is so far down the list of swans. He's been one of our most consistent players so far. Same with Kennelly and CBolton, they'd have to be my top 2 players so far this year.

Everitt has had one good game. and he rates higher??

Agree! He's been far better than Goodes AT THE VERY LEAST.

[ScottH]

Agree! He's been far better than Goodes AT THE VERY LEAST.

I can't beleive Goodes even gets a mention ATM.

[goswannie14]

I can't beleive Goodes even gets a mention ATM.

Isn't there some methodology that BMR uses to rate all the players?

[ScottH]

Isn't there some methodology that BMR uses to rate all the players?

Yeah, Votes in the media.

[reigning premier]

I'm surprised we have anyone in the top 50...

[573v30]

I'm surprised we have anyone in the top 50...

Still early days, facing the depleted Dees should be a bloody good opportunity for Goodes to get 30+ possesssions and kick a couple of goals too.

[giant]

On "On the Couch" on Monday, they had the top 10 players to date based on Champion Data & as judged by Mike Sheahan. Tadhg was 3rd on the CD list & Sheahan says he was very unlucky to miss his 10.

[reigning premier]

On "On the Couch" on Monday, they had the top 10 players to date based on Champion Data & as judged by Mike Sheahan. Tadhg was 3rd on the CD list & Sheahan says he was very unlucky to miss his 10.

What stats was he racking up on champion data???

Most media appearances??

Biggest media whore??

Softest non-Australian??

[BeeEmmAre]

Yeah, Votes in the media.

true - the Hun to be exact.
However, I'm the first to admit that it's not foolproof.
I almost fell off my chair when I noticed that C. Bolton and B. Mathews were not named in Swans best v Lions and J. Brown and L. Power were in Lions top three!!!!!!!!

[liz]

true - the Hun to be exact.
However, I'm the first to admit that it's not foolproof.
I almost fell off my chair when I noticed that C. Bolton and B. Mathews were not named in Swans best v Lions and J. Brown and L. Power were in Lions top three!!!!!!!!

I don't think those who write newspaper reports - and certainly not those who compile 'best' lists - bother watching the games if they can just read a stats list.

I reckon Craig Bolton and Tadhg Kennelly would be in the top 25 or so best performed players so far this year. You'd generally expect a couple in the top group from club that has won two games and could very well have won its other two. And these two have been very consistent over the opening month.

[BBBBH]

its good that none of our players are up there. why does it matter? as long as we win games everything is fine.

our 2-2 record doesnt suggest everything is fine at the moment.

[BeeEmmAre]

My Top 10 AFL players after round 5.

1. Daniel Kerr (West Coast) 40
2. Jimmy Bartel (Geelong) 35
3. Simon Black (Brisbane Lions) 33
4. Scott West (Western Bulldogs) 32
5. Heath Shaw (Collingwood) 31
6. Andrew McLeod (Adelaide) 29
7. Chris Judd (West Coast) 28
8. Gary Ablett (Geelong) 27
8. Cameron Bruce (Melbourne) 27
8. Nick Dal Santo (St Kilda) 27