AFL Top 10 players

[ugg]

Its an interesting approach but it all depends on how good the HS judges are, which I think many have concluded aren't very good at all. Perhaps you could expand it to take in other sources. I've found the sportal site's list to perhaps be more accurate in who I consider to have been the best players.

[reigning premier]

And

49. Jude Bolton 29
56. Peter Everitt 28
90. Adam Schneider 21
97. Barry Hall 20
105. Ryan O'Keefe 18
111. Nic Fosdike 17
111. Nick Malceski 17
128. Darren Jolly 15
128. Tadhg Kennelly 15

Hate to say it... But that's fair. Bazza has been @@@@ and B1 is going pretty well.

For sure, on his day, BBBBH wil smash up B1. Unfortunately, he hasn't had many days this season.

[reigning premier]

Its an interesting approach but it all depends on how good the HS judges are, which I think many have concluded aren't very good at all. Perhaps you could expand it to take in other sources. I've found the sportal site's list to perhaps be more accurate in who I consider to have been the best players.

Then again you go to super coach and Boyle got -7 for round 10. How does that happen?

Think that you'll find there will always be anomolies in every system.

[ugg]

What does SuperCoach have to do with this?

And are you asking how you get negative scores? In SuperCoach a clanger earns you negative points.

[ScottH]

You're saying Bazza deserves to be higher than 97 the way he's playing at the moment?
Notice there is nine points different between B1 and Bazza.
Bazza best on ground v B1 not in best this week = Bazza overtakes B1.
As for Eski, a BOG this week lifts him into the top 60.

I was more surprised that both of those highlighted, were above the others.

Very surprised B1 is so high at all.
Baz proves that 1 or 2 BOG's scores better than consistently good players.

[reigning premier]

I surrender

[NMWBloods]

By what measure is J Bolton going pretty well?

[swantastic]

This is more like it......

Re: Sydney Swans Board POTY - Overall Season Leaderboard

--------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Overall Season Leaderboard (After round 11)
25 - Malceski, Nick"Melcho"
16 - Kennelly, Tadhg
16 - Bolton, Craig
16. - Everitt, Peter
13. - Kirk, Brett
11 - O'Keefe, Ryan
9. - Hall, Barry
9. - Ablett, Luke
8. - Barry, Leo
8. - Fosdike, Nic
6. - Richards, Ted
5. - Jolly, Darren
5. - Schneider, Adam
5 - Goodes, Adam
4. - Mathews, Ben
3. - Davis, Nick
2. - Bolton, Jude
2. - O'Loughlin, Michael
1 - Buchanan, Amon

[573v30]

You must have plenty of money on "Melcho" to win the Brownlow.

[swantastic]

You must have plenty of money on "Melcho" to win the Brownlow.

Just a little but i've got money on him to win the B+F too.

[reigning premier]

This is more like it......

Re: Sydney Swans Board POTY - Overall Season Leaderboard

--------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Overall Season Leaderboard (After round 11)
25 - Malceski, Nick"Melcho"
16 - Kennelly, Tadhg
16 - Bolton, Craig
16. - Everitt, Peter
13. - Kirk, Brett
11 - O'Keefe, Ryan
9. - Hall, Barry
9. - Ablett, Luke
8. - Barry, Leo
8. - Fosdike, Nic
6. - Richards, Ted
5. - Jolly, Darren
5. - Schneider, Adam
5 - Goodes, Adam
4. - Mathews, Ben
3. - Davis, Nick
2. - Bolton, Jude
2. - O'Loughlin, Michael
1 - Buchanan, Amon

Where's McVeigh?????

[ScottH]

This is more like it......

Re: Sydney Swans Board POTY - Overall Season Leaderboard

--------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Overall Season Leaderboard (After round 11)
25 - Malceski, Nick"Melcho"
16 - Kennelly, Tadhg
16 - Bolton, Craig
16. - Everitt, Peter
13. - Kirk, Brett
11 - O'Keefe, Ryan
9. - Hall, Barry
9. - Ablett, Luke
8. - Barry, Leo
8. - Fosdike, Nic
6. - Richards, Ted
5. - Jolly, Darren
5. - Schneider, Adam
5 - Goodes, Adam
4. - Mathews, Ben
3. - Davis, Nick
2. - Bolton, Jude
2. - O'Loughlin, Michael
1 - Buchanan, Amon

Where's McVeigh?????

0 - McVeigh

[swantastic]

Where's McVeigh?????

McHack isn't even worthy of a mention.

[BeeEmmAre]

This is more like it......

Re: Sydney Swans Board POTY - Overall Season Leaderboard

--------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Overall Season Leaderboard (After round 11)
25 - Malceski, Nick"Melcho"
16 - Kennelly, Tadhg
16 - Bolton, Craig
16. - Everitt, Peter
13. - Kirk, Brett
11 - O'Keefe, Ryan
9. - Hall, Barry
9. - Ablett, Luke
8. - Barry, Leo
8. - Fosdike, Nic
6. - Richards, Ted
5. - Jolly, Darren
5. - Schneider, Adam
5 - Goodes, Adam
4. - Mathews, Ben
3. - Davis, Nick
2. - Bolton, Jude
2. - O'Loughlin, Michael
1 - Buchanan, Amon

Is this an opinion, or do you have a source?

[nat]

Is this an opinion, or do you have a source?

It's from the Bigfooty Swans board voting.