Who should retire or be traded

[CRV05]

My Misses know doyles Girl Friend and the word is he as put in a request to be traded backto the SANFL.

[DeadlyAkkuret]

My Misses know doyles Girl Friend and the word is he as put in a request to be traded backto the SANFL.

He'll probably star for the Power in 2009.

[sWAns63]

Do we top up with players like Haselby or do we try to get some good youngsters

[ugg]

My Misses know doyles Girl Friend and the word is he as put in a request to be traded backto the SANFL.

Cool bananas, we can get Josh Willoughby back.

[DeadlyAkkuret]

Do we top up with players like Haselby or do we try to get some good youngsters

Definitely the latter. We've been so lucky to see some success from Sydney over the last 3-4 seasons, and it'll be another 50 years until our next flag if we do the old Eade trick of topping up a fading list. The Swans still have some very capable players, we just need to weed out the crap and blood some youngsters.

[NMWBloods]

I said at the start of the season J Bolton, Barry and Crouch were finished and many criticised that call. All three are now a liability. Mathews is probably close to finished, as is McVeigh. Bevan is still borderline.

Hall is a worry.

[Missy]

YAY!!! I'm up for that DA.

[punter257]

jolly and jude for carlton's pick 3

[NMWBloods]

Spida was awful yet he does not get a mention

He was terrible, but he is carrying an injury.

the other reason was Roos refusing to change a dysfunctional forward line,

Forward line structure and entry into the forward line are hopeless.

The interesting one was Craig Bolton, awful tonight, i reckon he should be traded.

He made a few uncharacteristic blues!

[AnnieH]

Leave B2 alone. He did ok against some very tough opposition - the ferals obviously wanted it more.

[DeadlyAkkuret]

I can't believe anyone would seriously consider us trading B2

[Layby]

He was terrible, but he is carrying an injury.

Eyesight ?

did not see Rocca in front of him ?

or Cloke ?

or the Sherrin at numerous bounces.

Eye infections can be terrible

[Layby]

I can't believe anyone would seriously consider us trading B2

I cant believe people are stupid, but plenty are >25

[dimelb]

I said at the start of the season J Bolton, Barry and Crouch were finished and many criticised that call. All three are now a liability. Mathews is probably close to finished, as is McVeigh. Bevan is still borderline.

Hall is a worry.

I agree with all of this except that I'd swap McVeigh (borderline, but better forward) and Bevan (game, but made one or two unforgiveable clangers).

[NMWBloods]

Eyesight ?

did not see Rocca in front of him ?

or Cloke ?

or the Sherrin at numerous bounces.

Eye infections can be terrible

His decision making seems bizarre at times - probably what stops him from being a champion.