B&F Live Update

[swansrock4eva]

Just in from B&F - Craig Bolton 3rd,
Nick Malceski 2nd,
Drumroll please:



Brett Kirk 2007 Best and Fairest.

Onya Kirky!

No word on other winners from the night though.

[is2SWaNz]

Yay! Good on you Kirky!!!

[originalswan]

Where did Goodesy finish?

Thought he might win it or go close with his finish to the year.

[is2SWaNz]

he finished 4th.

[bennyfrou]

I told Kirk that he is the very reason I follow the swans and he was a humble as pie. All I could do was pat him the back and he looked at me and kind of understood wtf I was going on about (i think he was as drunk as I was). Don't anybody underestimate the swans in 2008!

[Zlatorog]

Speaks also volumes about our TLM voting and how RWO people can be biased as well.

Congrats Kirky, you've deserved it!

[woo]

did anybody else get good laughes everytime LEO barry or LUKE ablett's names were said...I was killing myself laughing.....or maybe that was the booze.
great night again at a swans function, defo get good value out of these events, and the players are great to go talk to , one note of a highlight which I have been cringing about since the second it happened,
no guess's for who went up to mcveigh and said "Hey Fozzy, you had an ok year huh".....yep....what a tool I am! but boy do those guys look alike close up...much like the Amon/schiedes combo...

[nat]

did anybody else get good laughes everytime LEO barry or LUKE ablett's names were said...I was killing myself laughing.....or maybe that was the booze.
great night again at a swans function, defo get good value out of these events, and the players are great to go talk to , one note of a highlight which I have been cringing about since the second it happened,
no guess's for who went up to mcveigh and said "Hey Fozzy, you had an ok year huh".....yep....what a tool I am! but boy do those guys look alike close up...much like the Amon/schiedes combo...

Do you know if Simon Phillips was there?

[Swannette]

Pretty sure he was there - small blonde man seen at a distance

[swantastic]

Speaks also volumes about our TLM voting and how RWO people can be biased as well.

Congrats Kirky, you've deserved it!

What drugs are you on,the TLM final finishers were pretty spot on with the B+F.

Final Leader Board after 23 Games(TLM)
44 Adam Goodes
43 Craig Bolton
38 Nick Malceski
35 Brett Kirk


B+F
Kirky
Melcho
B2
Goodes...

On the B+F Benny Mathews surprised me how many votes he got,good on him.

[Zlatorog]

What drugs are you on,the TLM final finishers were pretty spot on with the B+F.

Final Leader Board after 23 Games(TLM)
44 Adam Goodes
43 Craig Bolton
38 Nick Malceski
35 Brett Kirk


B+F
Kirky
Melcho
B2
Goodes...

On the B+F Benny Mathews surprised me how many votes he got,good on him.

What drugs are you on?

Obviously TLM voters were applying favouritism when voted for Goodes. Isn't that obvious? In TLM count he won. Did he win in B&F?

[ItsAllGoodes]

The two voting systems are very different...who was in front in the Brownlow?

20 ? Adam Goodes
15 ? Brett Kirk
9 ? Nick Malceski
6 ? Jude Bolton


Final Leader Board after 23 Games(TLM)
44 Adam Goodes
43 Craig Bolton
38 Nick Malceski
35 Brett Kirk


B+F
Kirky
Melcho
B2
Goodes...



Apart from the wrong Bolton....the three different votes got pretty similar results...so i would suggest youve simply got the difference between 3-2-1 type voting (which can favour a player who has a few very good games) and our B&F system which favours a more consistent, team-orientated player

And despite my screen name suggesting some bias in the matter...I am abig Kirky fan and i think the B&F result was spot on

[goswannie14]

What drugs are you on?

Obviously TLM voters were applying favouritism when voted for Goodes. Isn't that obvious? In TLM count he won. Did he win in B&F?

Don't let the facts get in the way of your argument.


The top 4 in the TLM are the same as the top 4 in the club B&F, so it seems the TLM was pretty accurate, and since it's inception, it is the first time that the TLM and club B&F have not been the same person.

[swantastic]

Don't let the facts get in the way of your argument.


The top 4 in the TLM are the same as the top 4 in the club B&F, so it seems the TLM was pretty accurate, and since it's inception, it is the first time that the TLM and club B&F have not been the same person.

Spot on Gs14.