2007 Scorecard - #9 Nick Malceski

[Zlatorog]

8.5/10

Agree with NMWBloods. Needs to work on his endurance. Shinning at the end of the season might be more important.

[satchmopugdog]

Let's see if he can keep his shirt on next year!

8.5/10

That was a highlight of the season and you want to take that away!!!!!!!!

[liz]

There are a few tough markers here. For a guy who'd played around 30 games at the start of the season to finish 2nd in the B&F in a finals team and to be deemed to be in the top 40 performed players for the season by the AA selectors is no mean feat.

He did tire towards the end of the year, but he was also one of just a handful able to hold his head up high after the finals exit.

9/10 from me.

[Claret]

MELCHO is a gun, easily 11/10

So is Malcho

9.5/10

I deducted half a point because he is all my sister-in-law ever seems to talk about between March and September.

[swantastic]

So is Malcho

9.5/10

I deducted half a point because he is all my sister-in-law ever seems to talk about between March and September.

Your sister-in-law is a good sort because thats all i seem to talk about.

[573v30]

8.5/10 - Great to watch, had a few quiet patches but played superb in the midfield and HBF when Kennelly was unavailable. If he continues his form into 2008, he'll get AA selection no doubt.

[giant]

A joy to watch - undoubtedly one of the highlights of the year. Opposition teams started to "work" him out a bit - will need to step up again next year.

[ScottH]

A few too many blunders for my liking from a player of his quality. 7.5/10. Hopefully he can con tinue to improve in 08.

Blunders, or just inexperience??

I expect him to have removed some of those "blunders" next season, as his experience grows.

[ScottH]

That was a highlight of the season and you want to take that away!!!!!!!!

He did get pinged for the tackle!!

[bennyfrou]

9.6 Out of 10

Great player, great year, great man to hang out with at the best and fairest. Although his girlfriend needs to understand that he is a Footy player and therefore popular but it doesnt mean he loves her any less.

[Claret]

Although his girlfriend needs to understand that he is a Footy player and therefore popular but it doesnt mean he loves her any less.

[bennyfrou]

9.6 Out of 10

Great player, great year, great man to hang out with at the best and fairest. Although his girlfriend needs to understand that he is a Footy player and therefore popular but it doesnt mean he loves her any less.

His girlfriend was all in a tiz at the club champ because he wasn't showing her enough attention because other people were taking up all his time.

[Jeffers1984]

9/10. What a rise from a player with only 30 games under his belt.

[AnnieH]

9.5/10

I'm as excited watching this kid as I was when Goodsey first played.

I expect bigger and better next year. Can't wait.

[i'm-uninformed2]

10/10 for me - for a combination of his play on field and the lady he's pulled off field. Truly outstanding!