2007 Scorecard - #17 Tadhg Kennelly

[AnnieH]

Rate away ...

[ScottH]

Too many games missed, most of which we lost.
A very important part of the team structure.

8/10, for the games he played.

[RogueSwan]

7/10 for the season. Proved just how vital he is to the team this year.

[BeeEmmAre]

Regardless of what anyone says, Kennelly is the barometer of our team.
No, he's not the best (Goodes), most courageous/inspirational (Kirk), most intimidating (Hall) or best defender (Bolton).
But he is very consistent, always does his job and is the lynchpin of our game plan.
When he was missing, we went missing, and his injury cruelled his (and Sydney's) season.
I expect him to bounce back in 2008 with a 9/10 or better year, but this year he just can't get that much.

6/10.

[jono2707]

7/10 This guy could win a Brownlow in the next year or two as long as he stays healthy. I'd put a few dollars on it anyway.

If he and Malceski both stay healthy and fire next year, and with Mattner coming on board, we 'll have some pretty potent running off the half backline to say the least.

[AnnieH]

Regardless of what anyone says, Kennelly is the barometer of our team.
No, he's not the best (Goodes), most courageous/inspirational (Kirk), most intimidating (Hall) or best defender (Bolton).
But he is very consistent, always does his job and is the lynchpin of our game plan.
When he was missing, we went missing, and his injury cruelled his (and Sydney's) season.
I expect him to bounce back in 2008 with a 9/10 or better year, but this year he just can't get that much.

6/10.

Totally agree (with half a point just for being irish!). It's a pity that injury let him down this year. I look forward to giving him a 9.98 next year.

6.5/10.

[swantastic]

Not even close between Tiger and Melcho,the latter wins hands down.

Tiger for the games he played 8/10

[Plugger46]

Not even close between Tiger and Melcho,the latter wins hands down.

Tiger for the games he played 8/10

I personally think Kennelly is the better footballer.

Injury plagued year - 8/10 for games played.

[swantastic]

I personally think Kennelly is the better footballer.

Injury plagued year - 8/10 for games played.

I agree Plugger,but only for the time being.I hope Tiger and Melcho become even better than they are know which in turn is good for us.

[NMWBloods]

Was awesome early, but injuries late were a problem. Would have been 9/10 for games played, but 7/10 for overall impact.

[Big Al]

7.5/10 Terrific when he was on the park but injuries reduced his overall rating

[Zlatorog]

Injuries, injuries... Being missed a lot.

7/10

[573v30]

7/10 - Injury plagued, played only 13 games for the season but for the majority of the games he played he was consistent and provided the run from the half-back line. Hopefully he's injury free in 2008 and that he plays his best footy.

[goswannie14]

8/10 for the games he played. Hope he can stay fit next year.

[Jewels]

8/10

Proved just how important he is to the team. No Tiger = No Swans.