Hall of Fame inductees

[TheGrimReaper]

That is a football embarassment. Of his era he was a mediocre player whoe received less Brownlow votes than even Dale Lewis.

Does anyone ever remeber playing Collingwood and being concerned about what Gavin Brown would do?

That is a joke

Why is it a joke? He was a great player and he was captain. Just because he received hardly any brownlow votes, doesn't mean he's a dud player. He is a champion. Very un-heralded.

[Reggi]

Why is it a joke? He was a great player and he was captain. Just because he received hardly any brownlow votes, doesn't mean he's a dud player. He is a champion. Very un-heralded.

He was a very mediocre footballer.

Name for me the great games he's played?

[TheGrimReaper]

He was a very mediocre footballer.

Name for me the great games he's played?

Clutching at straws there.

Do I watch Collingwood that closely. You don't go by freakin' brownlow votes to find champions.

[Nico]

Why is it a joke? He was a great player and he was captain. Just because he received hardly any brownlow votes, doesn't mean he's a dud player. He is a champion. Very un-heralded.

I'm with Reggi on this one. In Jack Dyer's words he was a good average footballer, maybe a touch better than that, but a great footballer, get out of here.

Longevity; yes, Captian; yes but a Hall of Famer, heck no.

I would have thought clubs would have paid far more attention to Tony Morwood as he was a dangerous forward than Gavin Brown, but Tony wouldn't even get a sniff of Hall of Fame.

What about Tuddy and "character". He was done for handling stolen goods twice, stolen tyers I believe. I guess as long a you are not on drugs and not fixing up someones missus then it is OK for Hall of Fame.

[Nico]

Can anyone tell me if John Nicholls is in the Hall of Fame. He did time for "things shifty".

My now deceased uncle a staunch Carlton supporter swore that he saw said player with a wad of notes as thick as his thigh out side the ground after a game aginst North. Played the worst game of his career and North did them in a big upset, mmm.

[TheGrimReaper]

Can anyone tell me if John Nicholls is in the Hall of Fame. He did time for "things shifty".

My now deceased uncle a staunch Carlton supporter swore that he saw said player with a wad of notes as thick as his thigh out side the ground after a game aginst North. Played the worst game of his career and North did them in a big upset, mmm.

List of Australian Football Hall of Fame inductees - Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia

Yes he was one of the original 12 legends.