Which player would we miss the most

[swansrule100]

with goodes being out and having had a fair stint without hall this year. Who is the most vital swan, who would we miss the most and would we be gone without that player.

I think kirk leads this side a hell of a lot, but the player i choose is jolly. Without him in the ruck i reckon we would be stuffed. He has also improved around the ground a hell of a lot.

He probably isnt our best player but if he was out for the season it would affect our structure the most.

I realise i have left a lot of options off the list like malceski mattner and kennelly but oh well sue me

[ScottH]

I voted Jolly, but B2 would have to be pretty close to the top of the list, as would ROK, this year.

[31 hard at it]

I agree with the Jolly comment as it is vital to keep the ball in for our midfield.

I just think that Kirk is always there whenever required.
Inspiration is a rare gift ... Kirky has it.

Everyone makes up the team. Kirk is the spirit.

[Jewels]

I agree with the Jolly comment as it is vital to keep the ball in for our midfield.

I just think that Kirk is always there whenever required.
Inspiration is a rare gift ... Kirky has it.

Everyone makes up the team. Kirk is the spirit.

Spot on. I went the Kirk option for the same reason.

[Big Al]

When the team needs someone to step up there is one player who does it more than any other and that is Kirky.

[thejones,s]

Spot on. I went the Kirk option for the same reason.

As did I......mr 1percenter always gets my vote...

[eggbeater]

Leadership aside (even though we have 2 other co-captains ), I think Kirk could be covered quite easily.

I voted for B2 simply because of our lack of quality defenders and B2 is absolutely vital in our defensive structure, moreso than Kirky is to our midfield.

[RogueSwan]

I vote other for Irish

[NMWBloods]

I would say C Bolton, Kennelly, Jolly, Kirk.

[573v30]

B2. KPP match-ups aren't the same without him.

[ScottH]

Malceski is on a 6 game winning streak, and hasn't lost a game this year.

[swantastic]

Melcho is on a 6 game winning streak, and hasn't lost a game this year.

Spot on Scott thats why i reckon Melcho would be the biggest loss to the Swans.

I cant believe Melcho doesnt even get a mention in the poll,what has the world come too.

[DeadlyAkkuret]

I was going to say Playfair, but realised I read the title wrong.

[ScottH]

I was going to say Playfair, but realised I read the title wrong.

LOL!!

[tasswan]

I voted for Kirk as he has won us at least a couple of games so far, we would be in a different position now if he hadnt been playing