Do we have a good enough rookie?

[JUDO]

Do we have a good enough rookie?
To come on to the list as a replacment for Davis. Is Brendan Murphy good enough to play seniors yet?

[DST]

Do we have a good enough rookie?
To come on to the list as a replacment for Davis. Is Brendan Murphy good enough to play seniors yet?

O'Dwyer might be worth a look in.

DST

[liz]

Space on the list is not an issue and hasn't been ever since DOK's injury was pronounced as season ending. Smith is clearly still elevated - I thought he was originally elevated for Meredith with his shoulder but either it was always for Thornton and his knee or he has been re-promoted after Meredith returned.

[sprite]

Why is there a constant speculation that a rookie will come straight into the seniors, when there are already players on the list ahead of them to use?

Rookies are rookies and given space to prove their value playing in the pre noons - plus to be added to the list when a long term injury occurs.

The question should be who can come into the side from the pre noons?

[ScottH]

Why is there a constant speculation that a rookie will come straight into the seniors, when there are already players on the list ahead of them to use?

Rookies are rookies and given space to prove their value playing in the pre noons - plus to be added to the list when a long term injury occurs.

The question should be who can come into the side from the pre noons?

It's called blind faith, Sprite. Not all of us suffer from it.

[goswannie14]

It's called blind faith, Sprite. Not all of us suffer from it.

I do, but not when it comes to the Swans and their playing personnel.