Brennan or Playfair

Collapse
X
 
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts
  • Chilcott
    Regular in the Side
    • Jan 2008
    • 595

    Brennan or Playfair

    IMO we can't have the 2 of them playing in the forward line (or anywhere else for that matter) at the same time.

    Their skills are deplorable.

    Therefore, if were to pick one of them, who would it be?

    I would go for Brennan. His kicking is marginally better and is more versatile.
  • barry
    Veterans List
    • Jan 2003
    • 8499

    #2
    Brenan could be a top player if he could kick.

    IMO brenan belongs in the back line, with him restricted to handballs only.

    Comment

    • johnno
      On the Rookie List
      • Apr 2008
      • 1102

      #3
      Brennan should never be dropped from the seniors. He is the only one in our side who can take a contested mark. Oh, almost forgot, so can Super Ted.

      Comment

      • Legs Akimbo
        Grand Poobah
        • Apr 2005
        • 2809

        #4
        Originally posted by johnno
        Brennan should never be dropped from the seniors. He is the only one in our side who can take a contested mark. Oh, almost forgot, so can Super Ted.
        I think they should groom Brennan for Bevan's role and move Bevan forward rotating into the midfield.
        He had observed that people who did lie were, on the whole, more resourceful and ambitious and successful than people who did not lie.

        Comment

        • reigning premier
          Suspended by the MRP
          • Sep 2006
          • 4335

          #5
          Originally posted by barry
          Brenan could be a top player if he could kick.

          IMO brenan belongs in the back line, with him restricted to handballs only.

          Sounds like Playfair!!


          For mine, Brennan. The kick is slightly less terrible than Playfair.

          Comment

          • jenky28
            Our Edge Is Reg
            • Jun 2004
            • 564

            #6
            Id take Brennan!
            Hes a total gun and i reckon forward he could be a strong marking target and give us more scoring opportunities!
            Teach him to be accurate infront of goal and we r set!
            OUR EDGE IS REG

            Comment

            • Plugger46
              Senior Player
              • Apr 2003
              • 3674

              #7
              Brennan and easily I reckon. More lively and actually has some body strength. Kicking is just as bad though unfortunately
              Bloods

              "Lockett is the best of all time" - Robert Harvey, Darrel Baldock, Nathan Burke, Kevin Bartlett, Bob Skilton

              Comment

              • connolly
                Registered User
                • Aug 2005
                • 2461

                #8
                Brennan and Playfair aren't really either/or options. Brennan seems to have more a future as a rebounding defender in the Leo Barry mould. He is so strong overhead that he can play tall as a defender. Reckon Playfair is a strong enough pack mark to make him worth perservering as a KPP forward into the post Hall/Magic era. Keep both, particularly as the West Sydney/Gold Coast madness will see a thinner talent pool in general for the AFL.
                Bevo bandwagon driver

                Comment

                • TheMase
                  Senior Player
                  • Jan 2003
                  • 1207

                  #9
                  Brennan would be a very very handy footballer if he could kick. His attack on the footy is sensational, and on the weekend created many opportunities from it.

                  Hopefully Bloods is correct about him, and he is able to improve it.

                  Comment

                  • Bear
                    Best and Fairest
                    • Feb 2003
                    • 1022

                    #10
                    Brennan continually handballed into trouble on Sunday. Also completely missed some targets with his handballs.

                    Took a couple of good contested marks though.
                    "As a player he simply should not have been able to do the things he did. Leo was a 185cm, 88kg full-back and played on some of the biggest, fastest and best full-forwards of all time, and constantly beat them." Roos.
                    Leo Barry? you star! We'll miss ya, ''Leapin''.

                    Comment

                    • dendol
                      fat-arsed midfielder
                      • Oct 2003
                      • 1483

                      #11
                      Being a shocking kick, I was hoping Brennan was going to be our new Dunkley when he was given a run of games last season. Unfortunately hasn't got the height to really match it with the the gorillas of the comp.

                      Comment

                      • reigning premier
                        Suspended by the MRP
                        • Sep 2006
                        • 4335

                        #12
                        Originally posted by Bear
                        Brennan continually handballed into trouble on Sunday. Also completely missed some targets with his handballs.

                        Took a couple of good contested marks though.
                        Originally posted by dendol
                        Being a shocking kick, I was hoping Brennan was going to be our new Dunkley when he was given a run of games last season. Unfortunately hasn't got the height to really match it with the the gorillas of the comp.
                        Seriously.... You two could be speaking about either of them.... Do a word swap and change Brennan for Playfair and it still works!!!

                        Seriously, there's a cigarette paper between them...

                        I like Brennan's hair though.....

                        Comment

                        • Darren Thomson
                          On the Rookie List
                          • Jul 2008
                          • 291

                          #13
                          Originally posted by Chilcott
                          IMO we can't have the 2 of them playing in the forward line (or anywhere else for that matter) at the same time.

                          Their skills are deplorable.

                          Therefore, if were to pick one of them, who would it be?

                          I would go for Brennan. His kicking is marginally better and is more versatile.
                          Neither please, bung Vespremi in the forward line and leave him there, let him learn. Those two have been around, can't kick or handball properly by now, never will. We need speed and Patricks attack on the ball was not to be sneezed at. Go the youg speedy Swans


                          Paul Roos for PM

                          Comment

                          • gossipcom
                            Senior Player
                            • Aug 2003
                            • 2585

                            #14
                            I'd choose Brennan over Playfair. Stlll think Brennan could be moulded into a Leo Barry type backline player.

                            Comment

                            • Jeffers1984
                              Veterans List
                              • Jan 2003
                              • 4564

                              #15
                              Neither, but if i was put at gun point then i would choose Brennan even though he reminds me of the nightmare called Rowan Warfe.
                              Official Driver Of The "Who Gives A @@@@ As The Player Will Get Delisted Anyway" Bandwagon.

                              Comment

                              Working...