Rating Swans players

[IrishSwanPerth]

Lately people are grading players in A= Best in the Comp down to D and I reckon we have only 2 grade A players
C Bolton and A goodes, we have a few in B ie R Shaw, McVeigh, Jolly.... but too many in C and D
What do you think??

[Bloody Hell]

Lately people are grading players in A= Best in the Comp down to D and I reckon we have only 2 grade A players
C Bolton and A goodes, we have a few in B ie R Shaw, McVeigh, Jolly.... but too many in C and D
What do you think??

I think Kirk is disappointed you consider him a C grade player.

[IrishSwanPerth]

Kirk for his role would be a B player, not for skill
Where would u put Hall, O loughlin, Malceski and O Keefe on current form
Roos likes grafters, like to see more skill in the middle of the park

[BSA5]

Kirk is A grade. One of the most consistent taggers in the game, picks up his 22 possessions a game, and his leadership on the field is superb. I've heard him described by completely neutral supporters as "the captain of the AFL".