Good on Barry for doing what he did, I think he was hard done by. But come on.... None of the incidents deemed reportable? Beggars belief I reckon. He should at least be up for the 3rd 50 incident. I guess it's the AFL's way of saying, "all this should never have happened in the first place if the umpiring was fair and equitable."
In defense of Hall
Collapse
X
-
Robert Walls has just pretty much said on One week at a time that Baz doesn't deserve to get the benefit of the umpire's doubt in 50-50 decisions. Basically Walls is saying that it's ok that Barry gets a raw deal on the pitch - beacuse he's Barry Hall & he's stuffed up in the past.
I would expect that each decision needs to be based on the merits of the current event - not on what has transpired in the past.
Whilst attitudes like Wall's exist, we have a problem.Comment
-
Robert Walls has just pretty much said on One week at a time that Baz doesn't deserve to get the benefit of the umpire's doubt in 50-50 decisions. Basically Walls is saying that it's ok that Barry gets a raw deal on the pitch - beacuse he's Barry Hall & he's stuffed up in the past.
I would expect that each decision needs to be based on the merits of the current event - not on what has transpired in the past.
Whilst attitudes like Wall's exist, we have a problem.
It's perfectly reasonable to expect each decision to be made on it's merits, but for Hally and the Swans in general, it's a pipedream.
The worst part of it is that the AFL just bat it all away - everything is perfect in their world - and they will never do anything about it. Makes a joke of so called umpire directives and the laws of the game.
Maybe Hally should turn up with a Matty Lloyd mask on against the pies - anything's worth a try!Comment
-
Comment
-
Comment
-
No we disagree with Paul. He's just doing his usual tow the party line bull @@@@Comment
-
Players give lip aggressively to umpires all the time - and if that had been anyone else but Hall, no free would have been paid. He is on a different footing to all other players - which is just wrong and flies in the face of everything the AFL tells us the umpires department supposedly stands for.Comment
-
I only support one team: The SYDNEY SWANS!!!!! :adore
Comment
-
Comment
-
Comment
-
I'd love to see Walls get a seat in parliament. Imagine the Hon Mr Robert Walls MP getting up to speak, "Mr Speaker, on careful review I believe it is clear that we are not getting sufficient effort from the police in order to quell attacks on Indian students... the commissioner is simply not getting involved... Mr Speaker, I propose we give the commissioner a run in the ruck!"I knew him as a gentle young man, I cannot say for sure the reasons for his decline
We watched him fade before our very eyes, and years before his timeComment
-
I'd love to see Walls get a seat in parliament. Imagine the Hon Mr Robert Walls MP getting up to speak, "Mr Speaker, on careful review I believe it is clear that we are not getting sufficient effort from the police in order to quell attacks on Indian students... the commissioner is simply not getting involved... Mr Speaker, I propose we give the commissioner a run in the ruck!"
It took 6 pages, but finally some sense has entered this thread. Well done StellComment
Comment