Kelli's commentary on TEN

[Robbo]

Big group on facebook wanting her gone.

[Xie Shan]

Hmm, I was watching Hawthorn vs St. Kilda the other day and didn't think she was all that bad. The monotone is a problem though. Perhaps it seemed worse because she was calling the game with Lane and Walls.

[swanny2]

i heard her for the first time in the Geelong game and god does she try too hard. i absolutely hate her.

[Bloodlines]

Kelli

When u judge blokes the same way you judge Kelli there may be an argument. I agree she tries to sound too much like a bloke and should just back off a bit. but she has great knowledge of the game and is perceptive. That idiot Spud frawley is the one who should be off air. We have a sweep when the Swannies playing as he seems to be in the calling team most of the time, , How long in before he says "The Swans love the stoppages Usually it is at the first stoppage. In that game against Port when we kicked 10 in the first quarter he was still going on about it. He is hopeless and Shaw not far behind him.
I like Kelli hird is a good color man gerard BT AListair Clarkson Matthews and Blight mypick not forgetting the Prince Cometti . Tim lane should be banned In 2005 GF when Sydney fans called out ball he sniffed gee they calling ball last week they wouldn't have known what it was. He Frawley Shaw and a few others r part of the Victorian mafia who still don't understand that it is a national game Leave Kelli alone she improves all the time and she by no means the wrst.

[Lohengrin]

Who is worse? Frawley is a special comments man, not a ball-by-ball commentator.

[GoSouth33]

Goodness....I think we're being way too hard on poor ol' Kelli. Ah....the travails fo being a pioneer....

[Wardy]

Goodness....I think we're being way too hard on poor ol' Kelli. Ah....the travails fo being a pioneer....

None of us are disputing the fact that she has a terrific knowledge of the game - in fact I feel she explains the game better than some of the blokes. However, its the voice that is grating. All she needs to do is have some voice coaching and then I feel she will be great. But for now - its still finger nails down the blackboard for me. (and I apologise Kelli, being part of the sisterhood and all, but we chicks have to be honest with each other)