Match Review Panel is a joke

Collapse
X
 
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts
  • SwansFan1972
    On the Rookie List
    • Nov 2008
    • 621

    Match Review Panel is a joke

    How can Zac Dawson be deemed to have no case to answer - arrives late to a marking contest and strikes an opponent's head with his elbow.

    He's now got away with a few cheap shots (round one against Tadgh included) but his number will come up. Hopefully!

    Quote from MRP:

    Contact between St Kilda?s Zac Dawson and Essendon?s Brent Stanton from the fourth quarter of Sunday?s match was assessed. The panel said that Dawson jumped in the air in an attempt to spoil a marking attempt by the Essendon player. He stopped his motion to spoil when Stanton had taken the mark and his elbow made contact with Stanton in his follow-through. The action was not deemed to be a striking action and no further action was taken.

    Must be the only player in the league who attempts to spoil with his hands down and a leading elbow ...
    Last edited by SwansFan1972; 17 May 2010, 09:12 PM. Reason: added quote from MRP
  • Matt79
    Bring it on!
    • Sep 2004
    • 3143

    #2
    I thought the same thing. Watching the game live, I thought he would get 2 weeks at least. The MRP is so inconsistent it is beyond ridiculous.
    Swannies for life!

    Comment

    • ScottH
      It's Goodes to cheer!!
      • Sep 2003
      • 23665

      #3
      Yet, Hair pulling is a big no, no.

      Comment

      • BeeEmmAre
        Commentary Team Captain
        • Aug 2005
        • 2509

        #4
        And Nason's hair just begs to be pulled
        wonder if there was a market on how long it would take?
        "It's up to the rest of the players in the room to make a new batch of premiership players next year," Adam Goodes, triple Bob Skilton Medallist, October 7, 2011.

        YOU BETCHA!!!!!!

        Comment

        • Jesse Richards
          On the Rookie List
          • Mar 2010
          • 292

          #5
          A player can be more severely punished for back chatting an umpire - 50m - than for knocking out one of our blokes ....

          Comment

          • Adelaide Swan
            Up There For Sydney!
            • May 2010
            • 326

            #6
            Didn't know Fremantle was a women's club, that was absolutely hilarious and absolute stupidity from the MRP.

            Comment

            • Adelaide Swan
              Up There For Sydney!
              • May 2010
              • 326

              #7

              Match review panel: round eight - AFL.com.au
              Last edited by Matt79; 18 May 2010, 03:17 PM. Reason: Cannot reproduce whole articles.

              Comment

              • Adelaide Swan
                Up There For Sydney!
                • May 2010
                • 326

                #8
                The bolded part of the post was absolutely hilarious.

                We're playing the Fremantle Ladies Football Club this weekend, guys.

                Comment

                • aardvark
                  Veterans List
                  • Mar 2010
                  • 5685

                  #9
                  Hayden Ballantyne is nearly as annoying as Stevie Milne. Someone will sort him out big time sometime soon.

                  Comment

                  • Bleed Red Blood
                    Senior Player
                    • Sep 2003
                    • 2057

                    #10
                    Just on umpiring, was it me or was there loads more 50 metres paid this week? I thought the average would be say, 5 tops per game. I think there would've been like 10-15 in the three games I saw. What's up with that?

                    Comment

                    • SwansFan1972
                      On the Rookie List
                      • Nov 2008
                      • 621

                      #11
                      Originally posted by Bleed Red Blood
                      Just on umpiring, was it me or was there loads more 50 metres paid this week? I thought the average would be say, 5 tops per game. I think there would've been like 10-15 in the three games I saw. What's up with that?
                      Flavour of the week ... the AFL umpiring department trot out a new area to focus on each week and the three blind mice become zealots on it the following weekend...

                      then it is summarily forgotten and everyone is left with a new grey area to be confused by.

                      Digressing ... the Zac Dawson decision flies in the face of all the decisions over the last few seasons where high contact was deemed to be incidental or accidental (most particularly in the act of bumping), but because it was high, the player got rubbed out anyway.

                      Zac is a very very lucky boy, but the footy gods will get him - assuming his own selection committee doesn't get in first!

                      Comment

                      • Matty10
                        Senior Player
                        • Jun 2007
                        • 1331

                        #12
                        Another strange decision, although not necessarily inconsistent with this year's other examples involving David Hille - he has also been very lucky.

                        Comment

                        • SwansFan1972
                          On the Rookie List
                          • Nov 2008
                          • 621

                          #13
                          Originally posted by Matty10
                          Another strange decision, although not necessarily inconsistent with this year's other examples involving David Hille - he has also been very lucky.
                          He's been saved by each decision being line ball - he could have gone for any one of them. When the three are viewed collectively it is obvious he is walking the line.

                          Comment

                          • Doctor J.
                            Senior Player
                            • Feb 2003
                            • 1310

                            #14
                            Originally posted by SwansFan1972
                            How can Zac Dawson be deemed to have no case to answer - arrives late to a marking contest and strikes an opponent's head with his elbow.

                            He's now got away with a few cheap shots (round one against Tadgh included) but his number will come up. Hopefully!

                            Quote from MRP:

                            Contact between St Kilda?s Zac Dawson and Essendon?s Brent Stanton from the fourth quarter of Sunday?s match was assessed. The panel said that Dawson jumped in the air in an attempt to spoil a marking attempt by the Essendon player. He stopped his motion to spoil when Stanton had taken the mark and his elbow made contact with Stanton in his follow-through. The action was not deemed to be a striking action and no further action was taken.

                            Must be the only player in the league who attempts to spoil with his hands down and a leading elbow ...
                            Quickly becoming my most hated player.

                            Two reasons. He plays for St. Kilda and is a talentless hack who snipes from behind. Totally gutless. I remember him @@@@ting himself in the NAB cup when BBBB feign to have a go at him. Took the biggest step backwards.

                            Comment

                            • Big Al
                              Veterans List
                              • Feb 2005
                              • 7007

                              #15
                              Re: Match Review Panel is a joke

                              Originally posted by Doctor J.
                              Quickly becoming my most hated player.

                              Two reasons. He plays for St. Kilda and is a talentless hack who snipes from behind. Totally gutless. I remember him @@@@ting himself in the NAB cup when BBBB feign to have a go at him. Took the biggest step backwards.
                              To be fair to Zac if BBBB shaped up to me I'd be in row 10 before I turned around.
                              ..And the Swans are the Premiers...The Ultimate Team...The Ultimate Warriors. They have overcome the highly fancied Hawks in brilliant style. Sydney the 2012 Premiers - Gerard Whately ABC

                              Here it is Again! - Huddo SEN

                              Comment

                              Working...