Teams: Sydney v Fremantle

[Matty10]

I guess I should be grateful that Barlow and Richards have been dropped. But it seems that the form players will have to wait until evry dud in the club with family connections has been tried and failed.

I am confused - who is he related to? It all seems a bit harsh - the poor bugger is yet to play a single game and is being labelled a dud - but then again I have not seen him play - I suppose I will just have to put my faith in the opinions of the coach, the match committee, and our captains.

[lwjoyner]

Agree on the Playfair notes, istnt up to AFL anymore if he was at all when he was dumped by the Cats. Ridiculous call to play him last week and even more ridiculous to keep him in this week, maybe thw call on White is Ok but he probably should have been given this week for Playfair and if he doent perform swap him for Mummy next week. Roos playing favorites again.

[Old Royboy]

I am confused - who is he related to? It all seems a bit harsh - the poor bugger is yet to play a single game and is being labelled a dud - but then again I have not seen him play - I suppose I will just have to put my faith in the opinions of the coach, the match committee, and our captains.

Bolton is young Heath's mentor - they like his attitude, therefore he is part of the Swans family!!! He may turn out to be a superstar and I hope he will, but on what I have seen this year I am far from being convinced. ATM there are better players and selection options available.

[Big Al]

I am confused - who is he related to? It all seems a bit harsh - the poor bugger is yet to play a single game and is being labelled a dud - but then again I have not seen him play - I suppose I will just have to put my faith in the opinions of the coach, the match committee, and our captains.

Not allowed around here... we all know better than the match committee.

[swansrule100]

white does need a run in the ressies, but i think he is a better ruck option than pyke. Bevan keeping his spot with no mcglynn in doesnt bother me that much, but id prefer vespa.

Unsure why heath ahead of vespa and odwyer but least hes young.

Playfair must be going to have a run in the ruck????? or we are conceding the ruck? its an odd team this week

wheres mcglynn?

[stellation]

Not allowed around here... we all know better than the match committee.

I appreciate that's your new thing, but if we aren't going to discuss our opinions then a discussion board is a bit redundant.

[Big Al]

I appreciate that's your new thing, but if we aren't going to discuss our opinions then a discussion board is a bit redundant.

Opinions are fine - What I'm reading from some is sledging and not reasoned argument. I'm not sure what the problem is with voicing an opinion but conceding that maybe the match committee may know more about our players then we do. My opinion is that White should play instead of Playfair but trust Roos and co that they know what's best for White.

[ugg]

Short highlights of Campbell Heath at the 2008 AFL U18 Champs

http://youtube.com/watch?v=3mmD_jaVUWM

He's certainly not that skinny anymore.

[BigD]

2 things.

1) Don't understand why White was dropped. Leaves us shorthanded in the ruck.
2) When is Ben Mcglynn back? I didn't think he was that badly injured.

[Peace]

2) When is Ben Mcglynn back? I didn't think he was that badly injured.

they can't find him.

[Matty10]

I wonder if LRT is going to pinch-hit in the ruck this weekend at some point.

I would imagine that Sandilands will go forward a bit to stretch our defence as well (has he been spending much time on the bench?) - in which case I would expect that Pyke would need to follow him down. This will be an interesting match to follow.

[Nico]

We are officially rebuilding.

[hammo]

I would imagine that Sandilands will go forward a bit to stretch our defence as well (has he been spending much time on the bench?) - in which case I would expect that Pyke would need to follow him down.

This is the part I am most worried about

[undy]

We are officially favourites for this game.

[Donners]

Playfair still in, White out. Glad the selection committee and I agree on something.