Shaw

[Southern Swan15]

Reece Shaw, he was good last year, 2010 however he is looking like a bloke who has no idear. Poor spoiling, poor decision making,poor maning up, poor everything really. He tries to get involved but his 1 good moment is outwayed by his 15 poor moments. God he is making bevan look like a brownlow medialist at the moment.

why is this??? did he over achieve last year or is he just having a bad start to 2010?

[nicko18]

he'll always be a collingwood player to me

[swansrule100]

hes ok, just always looks grumpy with his team mates

[Robbo]

Could be forced out soon IMO. Heath looked very promising today and I would be dissapointed if he was dropped ahead of Shaw.

[swansrule100]

Could be forced out soon IMO. Heath looked very promising today and I would be dissapointed if he was dropped ahead of Shaw.

dont think that will happen.

[BSA5]

???

Shaw started slowly, but has been very good the last couple of weeks, and was more than solid enough today.

[liz]

???

Shaw started slowly, but has been very good the last couple of weeks, and was more than solid enough today.

Glad I finally got to your post because I thought I was going mad. The skill level and decision making across the whole team was pretty ordinary today but I thought Shaw was one of our better players. He was certainly one of the players who lead the noticeable lift in intensity after half-time, and he was sprinting after disputed balls right to the final siren.

[Margie]

Glad I finally got to your post because I thought I was going mad. The skill level and decision making across the whole team was pretty ordinary today but I thought Shaw was one of our better players. He was certainly one of the players who lead the noticeable lift in intensity after half-time, and he was sprinting after disputed balls right to the final siren.

Certainly one of the harder workers today.

[aardvark]

Shaw was one of the better older players today

[Yuri H]

I thought he did fine, and I'm one of the first to start sharpening knives when things displease me.

[Damien]

Shocked by this thread. Shaw was one of our better players today, his run off half back and 2nd efforts placed him in a minority.

[KirkysSocks]

Ok disposal is iffy but god he gives 110% and you can't hate on him for that. The way he has embraced the club as well. Disgraceful thread.

[dimelb]

Glad I finally got to your post because I thought I was going mad. The skill level and decision making across the whole team was pretty ordinary today but I thought Shaw was one of our better players. He was certainly one of the players who lead the noticeable lift in intensity after half-time, and he was sprinting after disputed balls right to the final siren.

How I saw it too.

[Kirkari]

Don't agree at all. He looks angry all the time, but plays like a demon.

[Primmy]

Good on you all - that's how I read his game. Frustrated, but fought it out; and he is a Swan - inside and out.