Goal Umpiring - Chelsea Roffey talks

Collapse
X
 
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts
  • torpedo punt
    On the Rookie List
    • May 2010
    • 15

    Goal Umpiring - Chelsea Roffey talks

    Hey guys,

    I think you will all enjoy this interview - http://www.thebigtip.com.au/afl/excl...chelsea-roffey

    An interview with AFL Goal umpire Chelsea Roffey and asked questions about life, video footage etc

    Chelsea Roffey is the second ever female AFL goal umpire and the only female listed umpire in the competition this year. Chelsea was appointed in 2004 after fellow goal umpire, David Morris, resigned during the season. Chelsea is a journalist when she is not umpiring and I was pleased to be able to recently interview her, and obtain some fascinating insights into the life of a (female) AFL goal umpire.

    Questions that were asked:

    - Umpires are known to get abuse hurled at them, how do you cope with it and have you copped much over your time?

    - Can you describe a typical game day?

    - Are you in favour of bringing in video footage for goal umpires to eliminate possible errors?

    - Female umpires have been in the media recently, what is your take on female?s being allowed to become field umpires in the AFL?

    - What does training consist of for a goal umpire?
    Chelsea in the interview makes some very good points.

    What do you guys think of bringing in video footage?

    What are your thoughts on the matter?
  • laughingnome
    Amateur Statsman
    • Jul 2006
    • 1624

    #2
    I agree with Chelsea that there are so many facotrs to be worked out with video reviews, but come to the conclusion that the line would be too blurry about where to stop using it and how long to wait. On the weekend the Bulldogs player couldn't take his free kick from the Centre Square until, as the umpire explained to him, "the lights had flashed [to indicate ch 10 & Foxtel were ready]". Less time delays mean a better spectacle, and I worry that video review would bring unwanted and unneccessary delays as umpires lose comfidence in making the call themselves.
    10100111001 ;-)

    Comment

    Working...