alan didak or dane swan?

[maigu_]

who do you think is more explosive at collingwood?

Dane Swan & Alan Didak?

and would the swannies be looking at these guys for future additions?

i'm pretty sure Dane & Alan will be looking to go else where if they don't win the flag this year.

[Plugger1300]

Why would they be looking to go elsewhere exactly? I'm pretty sure that the Magpies will still be a force next year

[dimelb]

Explosive? Didak. Ballwinner (i.e. lights the fuse)? Swan.

[Triple B]

i'm pretty sure Dane & Alan will be looking to go else where if they don't win the flag this year.

Can you give us the reasoning behind that?

[caj23]

Didak more talented, Swan more consistent

Both tossers and both will be Pies for the rest of their careers

[Nich]

Didak more talented, Swan more consistent

Both tossers and both will be Pies for the rest of their careers

End of thread.

[Doctor J.]

Didak more talented, Swan more consistent

Both tossers and both will be Pies for the rest of their careers

Didak yes. Swan no. I'd take Dane Swan in a heart beat.
Not going to happen though

[Triple B]

Didak more talented, Swan more consistent

Both tossers and both will be Pies for the rest of their careers

Never really considered Swan a tosser. Don't particularly like his artwork, but he goes about his business quietly but well, rarely whinges to the umpires and appears to keep out of all the 'in the face' crap that some players like to do.

Didak on the other hand...well documented in other threads he is my #1 most hated player in the AFL, for all the same reasons I like Swan, makes me dislike Didak.

I can see Swan as a Pie for life, Didak however will probably @@@@ up again somewhere down the line and later in his career when he isn't the gun he is now, Eddie will come out with some BS bravado and give him the flick. He'll probably finish his career back at Port.

[Plugger46]

Never really considered Swan a tosser. Don't particularly like his artwork, but he goes about his business quietly but well, rarely whinges to the umpires and appears to keep out of all the 'in the face' crap that some players like to do.

Didak on the other hand...well documented in other threads he is my #1 most hated player in the AFL, for all the same reasons I like Swan, makes me dislike Didak.

I can see Swan as a Pie for life, Didak however will probably @@@@ up again somewhere down the line and later in his career when he isn't the gun he is now, Eddie will come out with some BS bravado and give him the flick. He'll probably finish his career back at Port.

I think Will might be referring to a certain incident at Fed square...

[Triple B]

I think Will might be referring to a certain incident at Fed square...

Fairy nuff. I have to admit I don't know that incident, I'll move on.

That said, I still like the way Swan conducts himself on the field.

[AnnieH]

seriously.
who cares?
as far as I know, our no dickheads policy still stands.

[dread and might]

Fairy nuff. I have to admit I don't know that incident, I'll move on.
.

Good player, however....

http://www.news.com.au/afl-star-dane-swan-joined-savage-attack/story-e6frfkp9-1225767938178

[Plugger46]

Fairy nuff. I have to admit I don't know that incident, I'll move on.

That said, I still like the way Swan conducts himself on the field.

Yeah, no argument from me there.

Neither is leaving Collingwood for the Swans though in answer to the OP.

[giant]

I think Will might be referring to a certain incident at Fed square...

Brad Scott said on AFL Insider last night that Swan was very close to being booted by the club around 04-05, implying there were several incidents that occurred. Seems to have cleaned up his act tho.

[Swandering]

Need to think very carefully before taking a Pie - they'd have to be indoctrinated into our club attitude.