Rate our list on AFL site

[bennyfabulous]

Interesting concept on the AFL site for rating each teams list. Was a bit surprised with some of the percentages for each player. (In particular Vez)

Have a look here

Sydney Swans Football Club - Rate Your List - AFL.com.au

[bennyfabulous]

Some interesting names are coming up from the other sides that the fans wish to be traded.

Brisbane: Stiller & Johnstone
Carlton: Johnson
Freo: Schammer
Geelong: Djerrkura & Gamble
Hawthorn: Dowler & Ladson
Melbourne: Paul Johnson
Roos: Harding
Port: C. Cornes
Richmond: Nahas & Tambling
WB: Hill, Hahn & Minson

[AnnieH]

Tambling?

They're joking aren't they.

I'll take Tambling if they wanna give him up.

[liz]

Bizarre - who are the 3 or 4% who think we should trade Mumford, either of the Boltons, Goodesy, McGlynn, Hanners, Rohan, Jack, Jetta et al???

[AnnieH]

Bizarre - who are the 3 or 4% who think we should trade Mumford, either of the Boltons, Goodesy, McGlynn, Hanners, Rohan, Jack, Jetta et al???

I was thinking that too.
Maybe just the wishful thinkers from other clubs.

[Primmy]

Wouldn't want Tambling, soooo inconsistent. However maybe we could realign him.

Bizarre - Trade Ted! who gets on with it no matter what the match panel do to him!
I guess Patty is the lovechild of a number of members who don't understand why he isn't playing seniors. I would encourage him to get a fresh start because you can get so bogged and on the treadmill if there is just no opportunity.....and the boys ahead of him are, well, ahead of him.
As for Campbell Heath - whattha!! He has played one season of ressies and I doubt any ressie watcher would want him gawwn. He has great hands. Keeper. Same goes for Nipper, Chris and Dill.....silly.

[Triple B]

Bizarre - who are the 3 or 4% who think we should trade Mumford.......?

Mr and Mrs Currie....

[aardvark]

Some interesting names are coming up from the other sides that the fans wish to be traded.

Brisbane: Stiller & Johnstone
Carlton: Johnson
Freo: Schammer
Geelong: Djerrkura & Gamble
Hawthorn: Dowler & Ladson
Melbourne: Paul Johnson
Roos: Harding
Port: C. Cornes
Richmond: Nahas & Tambling
WB: Hill, Hahn & Minson

I like Gamble and Hill. The rest can go elsewhere IMO.

[707]

This type of site attracts rubbish responses of course. I agree with the 2% who want to trade Hanneberry, maybe we could get a high draft choice for him and draft a potential gun midfielder :-)

Lop say 3% off every trade figure and that would make more sense for the obvious keepers.

What it does probably accurately show is how the general Swans supporter feels about a host of mid range players like Bevo, Ted, Vez etc.

[reigning premier]

Like these especially.....

Geelong: Djerrkura
WB: Hill

And at a stretch,

Hawthorn: Dowler & Ladson

[swansrob]

Is there someone pretending to be Bevo in the comments section? (Or is it real Bevo?)

[RogueSwan]

Is there someone pretending to be Bevo in the comments section? (Or is it real Bevo?)

Connolly?