Club B&F - Who wins what?

[Go Swannies]

Anyone want to take any guesses on who will win what at the Club Champion dinner?

Bob Skilton Medal, awarded to the best and fairest player of the 2010 season:

Rising Star:

Dennis Carroll Trophy for Most Improved Player:

Barry Round Shield for Best Clubman:

Paul Kelly Players? Player Award:

Paul Roos Award for best player in the finals series:

[ugg]

Skilton: Kieren Jack
Rising Star: Dan Hannebery
Most Improved: Heath Grundy
Best Clubman: Henry Playfair
Players' Player: Ben McGlynn
Paul Roos Award: Joey Kennedy

[SydAFLFan]

This is my pick,

Bob Skilton Medal, awarded to the best and fairest player of the 2010 season: Nick Malceski

Rising Star: Dan Hannebery

Dennis Carroll Trophy for Most Improved Player: Kieren Jack (revised as Grundy won it last year)

Barry Round Shield for Best Clubman: Brett Kirk

Paul Kelly Players? Player Award: Shane Mumford

Paul Roos Award for best player in the finals series: Josh Kennedy

[Big Al]

Skilton Medal: Kieren Jack
Rising Star: Hanners
Most Improved: Pyke
Best Clubman: Kirky
Players' Player: Mummy
Paul Roos Award: Joey Kennedy

[swansrob]

Bob Skilton Medal, awarded to the best and fairest player of the 2010 season: Jack
Rising Star: Hanners
Dennis Carroll Trophy for Most Improved Player: Pyke (is he eligible given he's a rookie listed player? If not Jack)
Barry Round Shield for Best Clubman: Kirk
Paul Kelly Players? Player Award: Mumford
Paul Roos Award for best player in the finals series: Kennedy

[RogueSwan]

Can Mummy or McGlynn win most improved even though he wasn't a Swan last year?

Skilton: I reckon SydAFLFan is on the money with the Eski (Jack really only became great in the last quarter of the season, not to say he wasn't good before that. You know what I mean)
Rising Star: Hanners
most improved: Pyke/Mummy (see above)/McGlynn
Best Clubman: H
Players player: Kennedy
Paul Roos award: Goodesy

[liz]

I think Jack will win either the BS or most improved. I doubt they'll give him the latter if he wins the BS. If he does win the BS, I think Pykey might be in for a shot for the most improved. (Or even Mal, if they take it as most improved since last year, rather than compared to their previous best.)

[dimelb]

Skilton: Malceski, Jack runner-up
Rising Star: Hannebery
Dennis Carroll MIP: Pyke
Barry Round Clubman: Kirk
PK Players': Mumford
PRoos Finals: Kennedy

[aardvark]

skilton: Malceski, jack runner-up
rising star: Hannebery
dennis carroll mip: Pyke
barry round clubman: Kirk
pk players': Mumford
proos finals: Kennedy

x2

[top40]

Anyone want to take any guesses on who will win what at the Club Champion dinner?

Bob Skilton Medal, awarded to the best and fairest player of the 2010 season:

Keiron Jack. However, its going to be really interesting and close, with Jude Bolton, Nick Malcelski, Adam Goodes, and Shane Mumford all in the running.

Rising Star: Dan Hannerbury. That's an easy one.

Dennis Carroll Trophy for Most Improved Player: Mike Pyke. To be presented by Brian Taylor

Barry Round Shield for Best Clubman: Brett Kirk

Paul Kelly Players? Player Award: Jude Bolton

Paul Roos Award for best player in the finals series:

Bob Skilton Medal, awarded to the best and fairest player of the 2010 season:

Keiron Jack. However, its going to be really interesting and close, with Jude Bolton, Nick Malcelski, Adam Goodes, and Shane Mumford all in the running.

Rising Star: Dan Hannerbury. That's an easy one.

Dennis Carroll Trophy for Most Improved Player: Mike Pyke. To be presented by Brian Taylor

Barry Round Shield for Best Clubman: Brett Kirk

Paul Kelly Players? Player Award: Jude Bolton

Paul Roos Award for best player in the finals series: Josh Kennedy

[Donners]

Bob Skilton Medal: Kieren Jack

Rising Star: Dan Hannebery

Dennis Carroll Trophy for Most Improved Player: Nick Malceski or Jack

Barry Round Shield for Best Clubman: Brett Kirk

Paul Kelly Players? Player Award: No idea

Paul Roos Award for best player in the finals series: Adam Goodes

[veramex]

whats the criteria for the best clubman award?

Bob Skilton Medal: Kieren Jack
Rising Star: Dan Hannebery
Dennis Carroll Trophy for Most Improved Player: Mike Pyke
Barry Round Shield for Best Clubman: Brett Kirk
Paul Kelly Players? Player Award: Shane Mumford
Paul Roos Award for best player in the finals series: Josh Kennedy

[Primmy]

Torn;
Bob Skilton Medal; Kieren Jack/NicMal
Rising Star; Danny boy
Most Improved; MikePyke
Club Man; Henry/Kirk Mr Ted Richards
Paul Kelly PP: Mumf or Benny - probably Benny
Roos for Final: Josh Kennedy

Bringing Back the 2 Percenter: Jetts for never giving up on that goal.

[aardvark]

Dennis Carroll Trophy for Most Improved Player: Mike Pyke. To be presented by Brian Taylor

Hehehe I'd like to see that.

Joey had an excellent first year for the club. I'll be interested to see how he polled in the BS.

[liz]

How about a guess at the top 10. My guess (in only approximate order):

Jack
Malceski
Mumford
Bolton
Goodes
Grundy
Kirk
Hanners
Kennedy
McVeigh

Not overly confident because I want to try and fit Kennelly and ROK (despite the injury) in their too.

BMac to poll the most number of votes per game played.