Club B&F - Who wins what?

[ugg]

Jack
Malceski
Goodes
Grundy
Mumford
J.Bolton
Kennedy
Hannebery
McVeigh
Kennelly

[liz]

Ugg

You don't like Mummy? Or think the coaches don't like him?

[ugg]

Ugg

You don't like Mummy? Or think the coaches don't like him?

Or I was trying to do a rushed job by editing yours. I wanted to rank those players who had played all or close to all the games over Mummy who missed three and was relatively quiet when Seaby was playing. Deleted his name and I forgot to re-insert it later on.

[ugg]

How about a guess at the top 10. My guess (in only approximate order):

Jack
Malceski
Mumford
Bolton
Goodes
Grundy
Kirk
Hanners
Kennedy
McVeigh

Not overly confident because I want to try and fit Kennelly and ROK (despite the injury) in their too.

BMac to poll the most number of votes per game played.

Very good, 9 out of 10. Jude would have been in most fans' top 10 list.

[liz]

I am surprised not to see Jude in there. I think he (and to some extent Goodsey) get harshly marked at times by the coaches.

[Reggi]

http://www.dailytelegraph.com.au/sport/afl/afl-star-kieren-jack-named-top-swan/story-e6frexx0-1225933050179

Well Deserved by Kezza, a great year

[Primmy]

Torn;
Bob Skilton Medal; Kieren Jack/NicMal
Rising Star; Danny boy
Most Improved; MikePyke
Club Man; Henry/Kirk Mr Ted Richards
Paul Kelly PP: Mumf or Benny - probably Benny
Roos for Final: Josh Kennedy

Bringing Back the 2 Percenter: Jetts for never giving up on that goal.

I am SOOOOOOO impressed with myself! Only got PP wrong in total.

[RogueSwan]

I am SOOOOOOO impressed with myself! Only got PP wrong in total.

But for six awards you named 9 winners!
Each way bets with

Bob Skilton Medal; Kieren Jack/NicMal

&

Club Man; Henry/Kirk Mr Ted Richards

&

Paul Kelly PP: Mumf or Benny - probably Benny

[Primmy]

details, mere details.....

[Jesse Richards]

I am surprised not to see Jude in there.

I was wondering about that, too. Also curious about ROK being in the top 10.

[Primmy]

I was wondering about that, too. Also curious about ROK being in the top 10.

ROK had a blistering start to the year, and although played a lot of it injured, he worked. The CC is based on whether a player is deemed to have done his job well, and to what degree above and beyond the call etc. Hence one or two getting totals of 2. At at some games it was about 6 blokes polling and the rest got nada. His rating was based by the coaches on how he worked with what he had. And he bloody worked.

Jude did ok too. Lots of middle range points, a few biggies,notably the game with the 26 contesteds and a few lows especially after he was concussed.

Some of the others had biggish scores one week and right down the bottom the next. You tend to remember the big ones.

Kirky did well, and notably MykePyke started out very low, and worked up to more than acceptable at the end.

Keiran wasn't all that flash to start with but it built and built and then stayed high.

Notably if Mumms had played those 3 games he was suspended/injured, he would in theory had surpassed Kiz. His rankings were consistently high after the start of the year.

[Margie]

Well-deserved win by Kieran. He has definitely moved up another notch as a footballer this year and looks to have a great future. Sounds (from reports by those at the Club Champions Dinner) that his speech-making needs some work before he becomes Captain of the Swans.

[ShockOfHair]

He may have missed the big prize but Mummo is still B.O.B.

[Jesse Richards]

ROK had a blistering start to the year, and although played a lot of it injured, he worked. The CC is based on whether a player is deemed to have done his job to the best of his ability. Hence one or two getting totals of 2. At at some games it was about 6 blokes polling and the rest got nada. His rating was based by the coaches on how he worked with what he had. And he bloody worked.

Jude did ok too. Lots of middle range points, a few biggies,notably the game with the 26 contesteds and a few lows especially after he was concussed.

Some of the others had biggish scores one week and right down the bottom the next. You tend to remember the big ones.

Kirky did well, and notably MykePyke started out very low, and worked up to more than acceptable at the end.

Keiran wasn't all that flash to start with but it built and built and then stayed high.

Notably if Mumms had played those 3 games he was suspended/injured, he would in theory had surpassed Kiz. His rankings were consistently high after the start of the year.

Thanks, Primmy, you have explained it well.