Final 8 could become final 10

Collapse
X
 
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts
  • swansrob
    Senior Player
    • May 2009
    • 1265

    Final 8 could become final 10



    More than half the competition making the finals? What a load of @@@@!
    We already have teams making up numbers in September - why add more? Way to devalue the game.

    Our own Andrew Ireland is part of the committee putting this crap together...
  • laughingnome
    Amateur Statsman
    • Jul 2006
    • 1624

    #2
    Yeah, this was floated in conjunction with a host of changes that the fans "had their say on" last year. From the AFL's standpoint more finals equals more money, but they should be worried about quality, not quantity. I personally think that the finals system was at it's best when it was a final 5 (of 12 teams), which was a) simple to understand and b) meant that only the better-than-average teams made it. Thrilling finals series happened as a result.

    With the final 8 (of 16) we have situations like two years ago, where Essendon made the finals with a losing record and was summarily pumped by a record margin. If you believe that was good for "the brand" then I pity you. I'm a staunch supporter of the final 8 (of 18) because it will be a return to that system used in the 70's and 80's whereby a finals spot is earned, not given lightly.

    In addition, the final 8 is a good and pure system, easy to understand and follow and clearly fair and equitable. I've not seen a final 10 model that isn't some garbled mish-mash of byes, lucky losers and unfortunate winners. That point compounds the issue, but even if they fixed it I'd prefer the final 8 (of 18 teams).
    10100111001 ;-)

    Comment

    • BigD
      Swans Tragic No. 1
      • Apr 2007
      • 394

      #3
      No way in the world. What a load of absolute rubbish
      Red & White forever.

      Comment

      • Doctor J.
        Senior Player
        • Feb 2003
        • 1310

        #4
        Spot on laughing.

        Its a crazy world we live in, when I find myself also agreeing with Mick Malthouse, but he is also right on this issue. The finals need to be elite, and I'd even like to see a reduction in the number from 8 to 6. Wont happen $$$$ rule.

        Comment

        Working...