Out means Out

Collapse
X
 
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts
  • blinddog
    Warming the Bench
    • Jan 2003
    • 349

    Out means Out

    AFL KO's concussed players returning to field | Herald Sun

    The basic story is, if you are concussed you are out for the game. So does this mean that with the 3 man bench, a player like Jude Bolton, or any other hard, dive in at any consequence, type player a liability?
    One vege patch at a time

    Looking for a beer? Look here,
  • liz
    Veteran
    Site Admin
    • Jan 2003
    • 16616

    #2
    It is bizarre that this is announced on the eve of a season, especially one where coaches are already expressing concerns over the impact of injuries on the already reduced interchange bench. Is this a not-so-subtle ploy by the AFL to ensure that substitutes are not used for tactical reasons but are kept in reserve right until the end of the game?

    I predict we'll see a surge in players disappearing down into the rooms to have minor injuries seen to in private - ie so that the club doctors can assess in private whether it is safe for a player who has taken a bump to the head is safe to return to the ground. rather than making it obvious that they are being tested for possible concussion on the bench.

    If the medical evidence is that players are at risk if they return to the field after suffering concussion (and clearly there are varying degrees of concussion) I don't have a problem with this. But if that is the way the AFL wants to go, surely they need to allow for a greater number of substitutes?

    And if they really want to cap interchanges, why don't they just bleedin' well cap interchanges????

    Comment

    • aardvark
      Veterans List
      • Mar 2010
      • 5685

      #3
      Originally posted by liz
      And if they really want to cap interchanges, why don't they just bleedin' well cap interchanges????
      That's far to sensible....they would have to find someone who could count.

      Comment

      • dimelb
        pr. dim-melb; m not f
        • Jun 2003
        • 6889

        #4
        Has Mike Sheahan got an exclusive or has he jumped the gun?
        AFL doctors looking at concussion issue
        He reminds him of the guys, close-set, slow, and never rattled, who were play-makers on the team. (John Updike, seeing Josh Kennedy in a crystal ball)

        Comment

        • royboy42
          Senior Player
          • Apr 2006
          • 2074

          #5
          Originally posted by dimelb
          Has Mike Sheahan got an exclusive or has he jumped the gun?
          AFL doctors looking at concussion issue
          It's become a bit fashionable to downplay Sheahan's effectiveness, especially on that Big site!

          My opinion is that he has the best and most accurate info available in Victoria. He is so often right on the money.

          So when this sort of question arises, I go for 'an exclusive'.

          Comment

          • Nico
            Veterans List
            • Jan 2003
            • 11254

            #6
            Originally posted by dimelb
            Has Mike Sheahan got an exclusive or has he jumped the gun?
            AFL doctors looking at concussion issue
            Mike Sheahan has always been the one to trot out AFL stuff and this goes back a few decades. He is clearly the go to man for AFL media releases.
            http://www.nostalgiamusic.co.uk/secu...res/srh806.jpg

            Comment

            • liz
              Veteran
              Site Admin
              • Jan 2003
              • 16616

              #7
              Unsurprisingly (since he appears to be one of - if not the - highest profile AFL medicos) Dr Gibbs is quoted widely in this piece on the AFL doctors' reaction to the new ruling.

              Football's medical fraternity split on stricter concussion guidelines

              Comment

              • unconfuseme
                Regular in the Side
                • Jan 2009
                • 681

                #8
                I wonder if the other five club doctors who object are all from clubs that have players who actually put their head over the ball as well?

                It is a tricky one, you can never uderestimate the influence of the Auskicker Mums ... they must be respected!

                Comment

                • Kirkari
                  On the Rookie List
                  • Aug 2009
                  • 1036

                  #9
                  Ridiculous rule. We can look forward to the lowest number of concussions in AFL history for the 2011 season.
                  Superman still wears Brett Kirk Pyjamas

                  Comment

                  • Primmy
                    Proud Tragic Swan
                    • Apr 2008
                    • 5970

                    #10
                    Kirky used to try to get back on when he was concussed.....because he didn't quite understand that this wasn't an option.

                    Last year we saw Peb and Jude concussed, and came back on, and they both took a few weeks to get their mojo back. I suppose its a case of telling a young bloke where he is at if concussed, and a case of expecting an experienced bloke to know, and that hasn't always been a good idea.

                    Its manadatory in most contact sports in other countries in the world, so......I am kind of for it.
                    If you've never jumped from one couch to the other to save yourself from lava then you didn't have a childhood

                    Comment

                    • Untamed Snark
                      Senior Player
                      • Feb 2011
                      • 1375

                      #11
                      Originally posted by aardvark
                      That's far to sensible....they would have to find someone who could count.
                      Surely there is an ap for that.
                      Chillin' with the strange Quarks

                      Comment

                      • BSA5
                        Senior Player
                        • Feb 2008
                        • 2522

                        #12
                        Originally posted by Kirkari
                        Ridiculous rule. We can look forward to the lowest number of concussions in AFL history for the 2011 season.
                        Goal achieved... at least, that's what the AFL will argue.
                        Officially on the Reid and Sumner bandwagon!

                        Comment

                        Working...