Who would you take?

[BillyRayCypress]

My recollection is that Eddie was a target too. Surely he didn't do it twice?

That is the footage but they have cut a few seconds off it. Eddie came in through the door and Plugger threw the crutch and in the process fell over himself. You can see that bit in the extended footage.

He never hit Eddie and only threw it at him or anyone else once.

Although from memory there was a bit of "caveat emptor" with the sale of some four legged friends.

[royboy42]

Wasn't Plugger coming out of an unsuccessful trip to the tribunal when he threw the crutches?

[Cpt. Kirk]

Eddie McGuire declares war on North Korea | The Daily Maggot

Does Sydney want to be next?

[Dirtyburt]

I will take Jessica alba, you lot can have cloke, Reid, Harry o, beams or all four. I will be too busy to care

[grarmy]

Wasn't Plugger coming out of an unsuccessful trip to the tribunal when he threw the crutches?

No. He had injured his leg and was in the doctor's surgery with his dad. Eddie was part of a media pack hunting a story and they had snuck into an unlocked door. Plugger simply let fly at the pack.

[aardvark]

I will take Jessica alba, you lot can have cloke, Reid, Harry o, beams or all four. I will be too busy to care

You're starting to sound a bit like BIG AL there DB..........

[swanspant12]

Cloke is staying at collingwood..tigers were prepared to offer $3.75 million over 5 years, but that was way short..he will get that money over four years with the maggies.

[Swansongster]

I saw something in The Age today about Beams signing for $1.1 million over three seasons and most mail would indicate that Cloke is staying. Is there any room left in Pies' cap for Reid? Would he come to Sydney if the opportunity arose? Do we want him?

I'd be for it. He could well be another one of those great trades we've been doing for years.

[Dirtyburt]

I saw something in The Age today about Beams signing for $1.1 million over three seasons and most mail would indicate that Cloke is staying. Is there any room left in Pies' cap for Reid? Would he come to Sydney if the opportunity arose? Do we want him?

I'd be for it. He could well be another one of those great trades we've been doing for years.

Welcome Ben, cya next season

[boroboy]

There's been some serious discussions at the Swans about getting Ben Reid-this has legs. Sam is constantly in his ear about coming up and by all accounts he isn't ruling out the possibility. The Pies will want something very good in return though....

[Melbourne_Blood]

Is that the word around town boro or do you have a man on the inside ?

[boroboy]

Straight from a current players mouth...

[Melbourne_Blood]

Damn, nice connections. You've got me all excited now.

[mcs]

Get him here is all I can say - would be wonderful to have the Reid boys at either end as the lynchpins of our team

[Ruck'n'Roll]

Reid V' Cloke
Reid would be considered the better option, younger, family connection, appears to score higher on the "dick-head'o'meter!" But, we have 4 tall defenders already, whereas our foward line looks fragile aand a behemoth like Cloke would make it impossible for any side to double-team Sam.