Shuey and Lynch

[Roscoe]

Add Beau Waters -

from Fox: Already weakened by suspensions to Luke Shuey and Quinten Lynch, West Coast were dealt another blow on Monday night with defender Beau Waters ruled out for at least a month following minor knee surgery.

With that dirty thug Waters out I will have to find somebody else to boo - he is a sniper. Weagles fans reckon he is hard and tough, he is a grub

Now I've vented my spleen. I have never rated Lynch - big and soft. Kerr is still a champ , Cox the best ruck in the past decade and Nic Nat is

my favourite player (swans apart) to watch. I woner who Sellwood will tag. Priddis is still getting heaps of touches and is using it better

Can't wait to see if Sammy can perform against Glass who is a gun defender

[Go Swannies]

With that dirty thug Waters out I will have to find somebody else to boo - he is a sniper. Weagles fans reckon he is hard and tough, he is a grub

Now I've vented my spleen. I have never rated Lynch - big and soft. Kerr is still a champ , Cox the best ruck in the past decade and Nic Nat is

my favourite player (swans apart) to watch. I woner who Sellwood will tag. Priddis is still getting heaps of touches and is using it better

Can't wait to see if Sammy can perform against Glass who is a gun defender

Priddis got BOG in the Roos game - hard to see how they could pick anyone but Cox but Priddis has been playing well this season.

[Matt79]

Shuey's will probably get down graded and will get 1 week. Lynch's trip looks pretty bad to me. Would be VERY surprised if his gets down graded or thrown out!

[Mountain Man]

Lynch is currently 3rd in the goal kicking list for WCE, and Shuey 6th (with 24 and 14 goals respectively). So they are big outs so far as goal scoring is concerned.

Darling leads with 28, Hill has 26, Cox has 19 and Hams 15. Natanui has 10 goals.

Scott Selwood has 8 and Kerr 7

[ernie koala]

Shuey's will probably get down graded and will get 1 week. Lynch's trip looks pretty bad to me. Would be VERY surprised if his gets down graded or thrown out!

I hope not, an elbow up into the orchestra stalls is a dog act and he deserves the 2 he got...especially considering he has priors.
Lynch also has priors, 90 odd carryover points, and therefore can't see any way out for him either.

[Swansongster]

I hope not, an elbow up into the orchestra stalls is a dog act and he deserves the 2 he got...especially considering he has priors.
Lynch also has priors, 90 odd carryover points, and therefore can't see any way out for him either.

I'm happy to be wrong with my earlier call that these charges may be dimissed on appeal but - perverse as it may seem - I would have preferred to play Eagles at full strength to see where we are at.

[Matt79]

Shuey's has been downgraded as ruled contact to the body and not the groin. 2 weeks for him.
Lynch up next...

[Jewels]

Shuey still out for two, nothing on Lynch yet.

[BillyRayCypress]

Shuey's has been downgraded as ruled contact to the body and not the groin. 2 weeks for him.
Lynch up next...

That is an absolute joke.

Last night on 360 degrees they were disgusted by the deliberate elbow to the groin.

So did West Coast produce evidence to show that the north player had no groin?

[R-1]

They used Thomas's reaction and immediate unimpaired movement as evidence.

[BillyRayCypress]

They used Thomas's reaction and immediate unimpaired movement as evidence.

Did they argue, Shuey was trying to get some life back into them but wasn't successful.

On 360 degrees tonight, they have discussed the Shuey appeal and Robinson was shocked that the Eagles accused Thomas of pretending he had genital pain. How below the belt can you get?????? So to speak.

Eagles said he didn't get hit because he got up and ran straight away and therefore it was not genital contact. Obviously didn't see that last Johnny English movie to explain that one.

So he got one week and then had another week added because of his record.

No news on Lynch yet however Robinson said that it was blatant and there was nothing to appeal.

[dawson]

I don't care if West Coast are at full strength or not. Just win.

[dawson]

Lynch gone

[Nich]

He should have got 2 weeks for the stupid defense.

[Dogzbody]

Good news. Lynch is really an unwanted distraction against good football, don't rate him, never have, at least he gets a week for low integrity!