2006 Grand Final team

[Number 43]

Just curious. Who played in the 2006 Grand Final but didn't play and get a premiership medal in either 2005 or 2012?

[neilfws]

Pretty sure that only Stephen Doyle played in 2006 but neither of 2005 or 2012.

EDIT: actually, this has come up before.

[Zlatorog]

Agree.

[ScottH]

Correct.

[Swansongster]

Correct.

At the risk of provoking debate and I know we have discussed it before but when you look at three teams in this table, I think 2012 team would prevail in a three-way round robin. The forward line with Magic and BBBH is perhaps a tad stronger than what we trotted out this year but elsewhere, across the paddock and onto the pines, our reigning premiers would be way ahead for mine.

[Alan]

Who were the emergencies for 05 & 06?

[ScottH]

Who were the emergencies for 05 & 06?

Malceski was one in 2005.

[Number 43]

Malceski was one in 2005.

I think Spriggs was an emergency in 06?

[Bloody Hell]

Dejavu

[ScottH]

Malceski was one in 2005.

Schauble and Vogels were the only other 2 on the list in the Record that didn't play.

Does anyone have the 2006 GF record?
I must've turfed mine.

[Alan]

I think McVeigh was also one in 2006

[goswannie14]

Schauble and Vogels were the only other 2 on the list in the Record that didn't play.

Does anyone have the 2006 GF record?
I must've turfed mine.

I have mine, but it is still in the plastic and I'm hoping to get some dollars off a WCE supporter on Ebay!

[Triple B]

I think McVeigh was also one in 2006

He played.

[ugg]

2005: Malceski, Schauble, Vogels
2006: Bevan, Spriggs, Vogels

I didn't realise Vogels was emergency for both.

[Primmy]

Vogels good enough to be emergency but...... where is he now?